WWE 2K25 Review: The Island’s Bizarre Charm & A Universe Mode That Makes You Cheer
Remember That Compile Wrestling Game From 2001? The Island Does and Does it Better Now.
Picture this: you load up WWF Betrayal in 2001, that weird GBC game where Stone Cold throws punches in a subway station, and you secretly think, “This is awesome.” WWE 2K25’s The Island captures that exact vibe—a lumpy, absurd detour that veers way off the realistic highway and somehow charms you anyway. It's the perfect excuse to buy cheap games and add this wonderfully bizarre chapter to your wrestling collection.
Nope, this ain’t MyRise or that mega Universe mode. We’re talking a wrestling survival gauntlet that runs on the nostalgia fumes of a busted early arcade cabinet. You’ll see canned cutscenes, bobble-headed characters, and dialogue so corny I half-expect Gene Okerlund to pop up and yell “You gotta see this to believe it!” Yet you keep grinning. Kane’s flames flicker like a dying birthday candle, and out of nowhere, you find a No Mercy-style mini-game that feels like a secret locker-room find.
Kusoge in all its hilarious glory, where the charm outweighs the budget by a couple of hundred Roys. You’ll love the dongle-shaped giant taco near the announcer’s table and the pirate ship that might or might not have Captain Santino on board. I dunno, I’m in.
You stare as your custom wrestler deadpan nods through a static-cutscene Rock promo. The animation looks like it’s on freeze-frame, the voice lines loop like a busted record, but somehow you're fifteen again, loading surprise unlockables like it’s still 2003 and you just heard that the roster’s full of secrets. The Island is the weird cousin of the 2K family, and somehow, you keep bringing it to the barbecue.
Wrestler Shenanigans: Brock Lesnar might dare you to jog a potato sack race, while R-Truth gets sidetracked looking for a treasure map somewhere. It’s dumb fun at its finest.
Is it eye-candy pretty? Nope. But like a pizza you regret eating at midnight, it’s still tasty. Think Def Jam wrestling or those retro WrestleMania arcade brawlers.

Microtransactions: Tempting, Totally Skippable
Yup, The Island’s got micro-transactions. Nope, it's not a money-grubbing disaster.
You’ll spend VC to make your character rock those torn-up ECW: One Night Stand rags. Want Hogan’s sea-foam '89 headband? Grind, or buy a few VC coins and skip the line. Thankfully, every piece is earnable in regular matches, making it a great time to buy cheap PS4 games and start building your ultimate WWE superstar without breaking the bank. That said, you’ll replay the same brawl a few times to pile up enough coins. It’s a grind, not a dagger, and smaller than the VC inflation in NBA 2K. Plus, it’s pretty funny to earn a “Golden Cowboy Hat” by beating Mankind in a pillow fight.

How The Island Rolls in 2K25: The Plus-One Nobody Asked For
Think of The Island as the junk-food section of the wrestling smorgasbord—totally guilty, definitely extra, and the calories are kinda fun.
For die-hard fans: the tiny hidden jokes and nods, like stumbling on Heyman’s old ECW promo clips, are worth a quick retro brawl.
For the Goofy Crowd: Think of The Island as MyGM’s goofy little brother who still thinks spreadsheets are lame. It’s pure fluff, but in a fun way.
For the Throwback Crew: This mode is a time capsule straight from the WWF War Zone. It’s a bit glitchy, but, honestly, who cares?
Now, if you want the hardcore wrestling sim experience, there are way better places to go in the game.

Universe & MyGM: The Meaty Part of the Burger
The Island is cute, but the real beef is in Universe and MyGM, and they’ve loaded the plates high this year.
Universe: Pure Madness Turned Up
Two-Night PLEs: Finally, WrestleMania is a two-parter. Spread the show across Saturday and Sunday, stack fiery feuds, and throw in a double main just like ’Mania X-Seven.
The Return of Promos: Iconic cutscenes are back. Picture Dusty Rhodes trash-talking MJF, or picture something crazier.
Cross-Brand Brawls: Book a full Raw-verse-SmackDown War, or toss a surprise NXT mainstay into the mix. The toy box is massive.
MyGM: The Retro Feel
Online Rivals: Go head-to-head with pals or randoms in GM showdowns across the net.
Throwback Bosses: Steer the show as 2003 Eric Bischoff, Vince from the Attitude days, or referee Teddy Long, who still fires out “Holla! s like clockwork.
Expanded Drafts: Scout the indies, wheel-and-deal for legends, and balance the spreadsheets like a pro.
WWE 2K25 nails what real fans want—bring back that GM mode buzz and polish it like nobody’s business.

Gameplay Tweaks: Dozens of Tiny Fixes, One Big Smile
The core physics still rumble like a beast; now they just growl. 2K25 tightens it all:
— Chain Wrestling: that vintage Here Comes the Pain vibe is back, lockups hit like a heavyweight.
— Ladder Love: climb and swing, then nail a shot on the way—transitions no longer feel like a load-screen detour.
— Barricade Suicides: leap, land, and the barricade snaps like it’s 2012 again. Small change, huge feel—everything’s just a little grimmer and more gorgeous.
Not a brand-new genre, but the sim’s walk is becoming a majestic run.

Verdict: Two Modes, One Party
WWE 2K25 is like that double vinyl where one side’s symphony and the other’s garage mini-riff. MyGM/Universe belt the polished symphonic anthem, then The Island kicks on like a cult mixtape—cooked and monetized, yet you still feel the passion spilling like a cheap beer at the finish line. One side balances smudged fun with a perfect 2K announcer’s voice, the other just keeps you wondering what raunchy power-up you’ll unlock next load.
Is it still a work-in-progress? Sure. But the work is—Royal Rumble with 29 surprise pop-in entrants. Can’t hit pause on that party now.