<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/">
  <channel>
    <title>Startrek &amp;mdash; Social Media Book Report</title>
    <link>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/tag:Startrek</link>
    <description></description>
    <pubDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 23:32:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <item>
      <title>&#34;The Sleeping God&#34; by Jesco von Puttkamer.</title>
      <link>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/the-sleeping-god-by-jesco-von-puttkamer</link>
      <description>&lt;![CDATA[#StarTrek #StarTrekTOS&#xA;&#xA;Finished &#34;The Sleeping God&#34; by Jesco von Puttkamer.&#xA;&#xA;Cover art of the Star Trek short story collection &#34;Star Trek: The New Voyages 2&#34; Enterprise is pictured parked next to what looks like the wreckage of some kind of station in orbit of a planet.&#xA;&#xA;A giant alien supercomputer calling itself the Nagha in orbit of its builder&#39;s home planet becomes sentient and begins attacking and destroying multiple planets throughout the galaxy.&#xA;&#xA;You see! This is why we don&#39;t put AI datacenters in space, people! Star Trek tried to warn us!&#xA;&#xA;!--more--&#xA;&#xA;Enterprise is part of a Starfleet task force send to deal with the mysterious sphere shaped ship cutting a swath through Federation space. They are contacted by a Starfleet admiral, and diverted Raga&#39;s planet to pick up passengers for… reasons. One of these &#39;passengers&#39; is Singa the Sleeper, also known as &#34;The Sleeping God&#34;. A highly intelligent and apparently telepathic human mutant in voluntary suspended animation.&#xA;&#xA;So Enterprise goes to Raga&#39;s planet, picks up Singa and his entourage, including his priest, Manda-Rao. Who apparently Uhura finds somewhat attractive. Then the sphere they were chasing earlier changes its course toward Raga&#39;s planet, and a direct intercept course toward Enterprise.&#xA;&#xA;A battle ensues, in which Kirk apparently has an out of body experience, and Sulu keeps putting in course corrections that Kirk didn&#39;t order, and Kirk chastises him for it. They barely manage to put a dent in it, before it breaks off back toward Federation Space.&#xA;&#xA;Instead of pursuing the sphere ship, Kirk makes the decision to backtrack its course to its origin. They get there only to discover a star without any planets. After a time, another sphere ship just sort of appears. Enterprise was able to catch it by surprise and destroy it, but then another one appears, and has its shields up. Enterprise is barely able to scratch the paint before it too breaks off and heads to Federation space.&#xA;&#xA;Sulu absentmindedly pilots the ship into the hyperspace… subspace… time warp… whatever that the sphere came through, and they find themselves in another universe. Then Kirk gets zapped by… something, and wakes up in Singa&#39;s quarters with the ship completely empty.&#xA;&#xA;Turns out Singa, even though he was asleep, somehow knew that the first sphere ship was headed for his home planet, and decided he needed to be involved. It was he that diverted the Enterprise to pick him up so that he could play his part, and he that was influencing Kirk and Sulu during the battle.&#xA;&#xA;The Nagha has the ability to manipulate organic beings, something it calls the Seegh force. Singa shielded Kirk from it long enough to get him to safety, while the Nagha took over the bodies of the rest of the crew and compelled them to abandon ship. Now Singa, Manda-Rao, and Kirk need to team up to get the crew back and defeat the Nagha.&#xA;&#xA;My reading schedule is actually ahead of my summaries for once. So as I was writing the summary, my memory was so fuzzy that I decided to take the unusual step of rereading it. And I appreciated it more the 2nd time through. &#xA;&#xA;On the one hand, it&#39;s a relic of its time; with some outdated notions of Eastern mysticism that are a little uncomfortable in retrospect. I&#39;m not saying that one couldn&#39;t write something like this today. But one&#39;s editors might offer a few notes that one ought to take into serious consideration.&#xA;&#xA;But in a way, it&#39;s somewhat timely. A benevolent mutant superhuman versus a malevolent mutant AI bent on destroying all life, and consuming not only its own universe, but any others it can infest speaks to the existential creep of invasive technology like Gen AI.&#xA;&#xA;]]&gt;</description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="/social-media-book-report/tag:StarTrek" class="hashtag" rel="nofollow"><span>#</span><span class="p-category">StarTrek</span></a> <a href="/social-media-book-report/tag:StarTrekTOS" class="hashtag" rel="nofollow"><span>#</span><span class="p-category">StarTrekTOS</span></a></p>

<p>Finished “The Sleeping God” by Jesco von Puttkamer.</p>

<p><img src="https://pixelfed.social/storage/m/_v2/860925387620473976/4796c06ff-5eacf7/u0Tem2gBjzul/3u2PBcl4H5M0DiAYX4tSXj29KlB5GRBySUb3wZJo.png" alt="Cover art of the Star Trek short story collection &#34;Star Trek: The New Voyages 2&#34; Enterprise is pictured parked next to what looks like the wreckage of some kind of station in orbit of a planet."></p>

<p>A giant alien supercomputer calling itself the Nagha in orbit of its builder&#39;s home planet becomes sentient and begins attacking and destroying multiple planets throughout the galaxy.</p>

<p>You see! This is why we don&#39;t put AI datacenters in space, people! Star Trek tried to warn us!</p>



<p>Enterprise is part of a Starfleet task force send to deal with the mysterious sphere shaped ship cutting a swath through Federation space. They are contacted by a Starfleet admiral, and diverted Raga&#39;s planet to pick up passengers for… reasons. One of these &#39;passengers&#39; is Singa the Sleeper, also known as “The Sleeping God”. A highly intelligent and apparently telepathic human mutant in voluntary suspended animation.</p>

<p>So Enterprise goes to Raga&#39;s planet, picks up Singa and his entourage, including his priest, Manda-Rao. Who apparently Uhura finds somewhat attractive. Then the sphere they were chasing earlier changes its course toward Raga&#39;s planet, and a direct intercept course toward Enterprise.</p>

<p>A battle ensues, in which Kirk apparently has an out of body experience, and Sulu keeps putting in course corrections that Kirk didn&#39;t order, and Kirk chastises him for it. They barely manage to put a dent in it, before it breaks off back toward Federation Space.</p>

<p>Instead of pursuing the sphere ship, Kirk makes the decision to backtrack its course to its origin. They get there only to discover a star without any planets. After a time, another sphere ship just sort of appears. Enterprise was able to catch it by surprise and destroy it, but then another one appears, and has its shields up. Enterprise is barely able to scratch the paint before it too breaks off and heads to Federation space.</p>

<p>Sulu absentmindedly pilots the ship into the hyperspace… subspace… time warp… whatever that the sphere came through, and they find themselves in another universe. Then Kirk gets zapped by… something, and wakes up in Singa&#39;s quarters with the ship completely empty.</p>

<p>Turns out Singa, even though he was asleep, somehow knew that the first sphere ship was headed for his home planet, and decided he needed to be involved. It was he that diverted the Enterprise to pick him up so that he could play his part, and he that was influencing Kirk and Sulu during the battle.</p>

<p>The Nagha has the ability to manipulate organic beings, something it calls the Seegh force. Singa shielded Kirk from it long enough to get him to safety, while the Nagha took over the bodies of the rest of the crew and compelled them to abandon ship. Now Singa, Manda-Rao, and Kirk need to team up to get the crew back and defeat the Nagha.</p>

<p>My reading schedule is actually ahead of my summaries for once. So as I was writing the summary, my memory was so fuzzy that I decided to take the unusual step of rereading it. And I appreciated it more the 2nd time through.</p>

<p>On the one hand, it&#39;s a relic of its time; with some outdated notions of Eastern mysticism that are a little uncomfortable in retrospect. I&#39;m not saying that one couldn&#39;t write something like this today. But one&#39;s editors might offer a few notes that one ought to take into serious consideration.</p>

<p>But in a way, it&#39;s somewhat timely. A benevolent mutant superhuman versus a malevolent mutant AI bent on destroying all life, and consuming not only its own universe, but any others it can infest speaks to the existential creep of invasive technology like Gen AI.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
      <guid>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/the-sleeping-god-by-jesco-von-puttkamer</guid>
      <pubDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 14:35:19 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title>&#34;Crisis on Centaurus&#34; by Brad Ferguson.</title>
      <link>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/crisis-on-centaurus-by-brad-ferguson</link>
      <description>&lt;![CDATA[Finished &#34;Crisis on Centaurus&#34; by Brad Ferguson.&#xA;&#xA;![Cover art of the Star Trek novel &#34;Crisis on Centaurus&#34; by Brad Ferguson. Kirk is pictured on the right, and Spock on the left. In the center is Joanna McCoy wearing a green shirt with something on it I can&#39;t quite make out; possibly the top of a tree. In the background is a structure of some kind engulfed in flame. The tag line reads &#34;Enterprise to the Rescue! Kirk must save both a planet and McCoy&#39;s Daughter!&#34;&#xA;](https://pxscdn.com/public/m/_v2/860925387620473976/4796c06ff-5eacf7/qloQA0jrO10J/mACjEL5OqPeM6As7eZ8lWPD6Iv7OoI7oF00eQUav.png)&#xA;&#xA;The story opens at New Athens Spaceport on the Federation colony of Centaurus in the Alpha Centauri system. We get an image of a busy travel hub with somewhat anachronistic product placement, which immediately brings to mind the famous &#39;soup&#39; debacle. My copy is First Edition, but it was printed in Canada, so if someone with access to an American printing wants to check if they see blatant mentions of brand names like American Express or Coca-Cola, or if that was something that got added by a sneaky printer. Memory Beta mentions them, so I suppose it&#39;s in the original manuscript. There are a few oblique references like this lightly peppered throughout. Sears Robuck gets a shoutout later in the book too. Which is a corporation that no longer exists IRL. But this is about as intrusive as they get.&#xA;&#xA;!--more--&#xA;&#xA;Remember traveler&#39;s cheques? If you&#39;re on the Gen X side of the Xennial spectrum like me, you might remember them as things your parents might use on vacation, or that you&#39;d see commercials for, but that few if any of us ever had a chance to actually use before electronic payment became a thing. This is relevant because the story begins with a Telarite getting angry at an American Express ATM that took his card when he tried to buy some traveler&#39;s cheques, and wouldn&#39;t give it back. If American Express paid for this product placement, the joke is on them with the banter that follows the destruction of the machine.&#xA;&#xA;The police investigating this disturbance notice a man sitting nearby with a box. The first cop questions him, and is about to move on when his partner recognizes him as a local hate monger, wanted criminal, and all around piece of shit Isidore Holtzman. As they&#39;re about to bring him into custody, whatever Holtzman is carrying in the box blows up. The spaceport and much of the city are destroyed.&#xA;&#xA;Meanwhile, on Enterprise, all hell is breaking loose. A critical computer failure causes multiple systems to go offline, including artificial gravity. They manage to get back into normal working order and are planning to set out for Starbase 7 for repairs, when they receive the news of Centaurus, and are diverted to render aid. There&#39;s still no official word on casualties, as the disaster is still unfolding, but there are several on the crew with families on Centaurus, some who might have been at New Athans at the time of the explosion, including Bones&#39; daughter, Joanna McCoy, who was a medical student at New Athens. Her fate is still unknown.&#xA;&#xA;There&#39;s a flashback, where we get a glimpse of Kirk and McCoy&#39;s first meeting 12 years prior, when then-lieutenant Kirk is injured in combat aboard the Farragut, and McCoy oversees his rehabilitation. Near the end of his medical leave, they take a trip together to Centaurus, and meet McCoy&#39;s family, including Joanna, who was a child back then. Kirk makes a claim to a spot of land outside of New Athens.&#xA;&#xA;Back from the flashback, Enterprise arrives at Centaurus, and finds they&#39;re unable to approach the planet because the planet&#39;s defense system is indiscriminately targeting every ship that approaches, and is believed responsible for the destruction of hospital and relief ships that were due to arrive ahead of Enterprise. Enterprise tanks a nuke, and manages to contact the acting president.&#xA;&#xA;Transporters are offline, as the Enterprise is still crippled by computer failure. And the system is flooded by tachyon radiation from the explosion, so they wouldn&#39;t be a good idea anyway. So Kirk, Sulu, and their party take Galileo to meet up with the planetary government, while Spock, Chekov, and their party take Copernicus to the planetary defense center to see if they can shut down the missile defense system.&#xA;&#xA;Uhura takes command for the first time, if you don&#39;t count novels that hadn&#39;t been written yet. And the novel makes a point to call this out. She&#39;s arguably had the conn several times. You could say it&#39;s her first time in command during a crisis, but she commanded the ship during the battle of Starbase 12 in the &#34;Errand of Fury&#34; series, and single-handedly commanded from Auxiliary Control during &#34;A Choice of Catastrophes&#34;, both of which were set before this. And while she did take command in an episode of TAS, that event was set in-universe after the novel, which was printed later. So this is the first time Uhura took command in print after already but not yet taking command a year from now. Yes, I&#39;m trying to deliberately mangle that to be funny. But this is probably the first time she would have taken command chronologically at time of printing. Unless I&#39;m forgetting any. So it&#39;s not incorrect.&#xA;&#xA;It&#39;s revealed that a fringe political movement called the League for a Pure Humanity is responsible for the explosion. This group wants to expel all non-human aliens from Centaurus. You know; racists. And they&#39;re not just your garden variety &#34;speciest against fictional aliens as allegory&#34; racists. They&#39;re actual white supremacists. They&#39;ll tolerate non-white humans to a point, if it suits their short-term purpose. But much like racists in real life, if you think you can trust them because they&#39;re not currently targeting you, you&#39;re a rube. If you&#39;re a member of a historically targeted demographic that they seem to momentarily tolerate while they target someone else, they would eventually turn on you too if they get the chance. Real pieces of shit.&#xA;&#xA;The main tension of the novel is a jurisdiction issue between Centaurus and the Federation. The leader of the &#34;League&#34;, Isidore Holtzman, and many other high-leadership figures died in the explosion. But the remaining LPH leadership figures are still in the wind. Terrorist murder is a capital offense on Centaurus, and the acting Minister of Security Nathaniel Burke wants them to face Centaurian justice, and possibly the death penalty. But because an antimatter device was used in a terrorist attack, the Federation has jurisdiction. And Kirk is under orders to apprehend them and bring them back to Earth for trial.  Federation civilian court has no death penalty, so if convicted in a Federation court, they&#39;ll be sentenced to a cushy rehab colony. So the race is on between Kirk and the local Centaurian authorities to apprehend them first.&#xA;&#xA;Meanwhile, Spock&#39;s party manages to shut down the defense system so that ships can approach the system again, and sets out in search of survivors. They find a makeshift settlement of survivors, and begin the process of supplying aid.&#xA;&#xA;For a novel about a disaster response, I figured there&#39;d be a bit more urgency in responding to disaster. Kirk&#39;s party spends a night at a hotel in McIverson, another town some distance away. Sulu even manages to spend a night on the town, and the nightlife is described as a town going about their lives as though the capital city of their colony wasn&#39;t rendered a smoking crater less than a week ago. Spock and Chekov&#39;s party, after shutting down the defense system, spend a night camping out before setting out the next day on a search for survivors. The local government is so inept that the author feels it necessary to address in the epilogue.&#xA;&#xA;The book was released in 1986, well before 9/11. But 9/11 is probably one of the more prominent events that many of us in the west, particularly in the US or Canada could relate to, and more likely to draw comparison. And as someone who remembers 9/11, many of us were in shock for well over a week, and the effort on the ground was around the clock.  A novel like this has to hit different after 2001 than it would have before. So that kindof lead me to feel that the tone of the novel was a bit off. Though granted, for my generation and younger, it often feels like we&#39;ve been living a prolonged series of disasters ever since. Many of them inflicted upon us by our own governments and their corporate overlords. So in that sense; well played, novel. Well played.&#xA;&#xA;My guess is the author felt that other plot lines were more interesting than a prolonged disaster response sequence. And narratively, it was a good choice, and the novel is better for it. But it makes that aspect conspicuous by its absence.&#xA;&#xA;There are a more than few vestigial remains of a different novel that was planned, but then decidedly changed in the process. And I don&#39;t disagree. Some of those threads probably weren&#39;t going to go where they wanted them to, and had to be tied off. &#xA;&#xA;When we last saw Joanna McCoy chronologically in-universe, it was in the Star Trek Legacies novel &#34;Best Defense&#34;. Another novel that hadn&#39;t been written yet. There, she is a smart, and capable medical student who keeps getting taken hostage, but doesn&#39;t fold into the damsel role easily. She&#39;s an active participant in the plot. If you want to get to know her better, I&#39;d suggest that novel over this one. In this one, she&#39;s a little busy, providing medical assistance to the wounded at the recovery center. If she were a real person, who could blame her? But she&#39;s not a real person. She&#39;s a fictional character who we&#39;re supposed to care about, and not just vicariously though McCoy. Who also doesn&#39;t heavily feature in ⅔ of the novel. She&#39;s still smart. Still capable. Just… you know… kinda busy. So we get Kirk and McCoy&#39;s relief on finding her alive, but not much more than that.&#xA;&#xA;Plot points that do get explored are still engaging. I could nitpick them to death, if I wanted to dwell on it, but I&#39;ve been procrastinating this entry enough as it is. There&#39;s the theme of justice versus revenge; Should the surviving LPH members be executed by the state for the murder of millions? Or is it right that they be sentenced to a soft life on a Federation penal colony, even if it&#39;s a life sentence? Is the death sentence justice, or just revenge? It&#39;s a tension that doesn&#39;t get answered easily, and is ultimately left up to the reader. And I suppose that&#39;s the right choice. There&#39;s not supposed to be an easy answer; just a scenario to consider. &#xA;&#xA;StarTrek]]&gt;</description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Finished “Crisis on Centaurus” by Brad Ferguson.</p>

<p><img src="https://pxscdn.com/public/m/_v2/860925387620473976/4796c06ff-5eacf7/qloQA0jrO10J/mACjEL5OqPeM6As7eZ8lWPD6Iv7OoI7oF00eQUav.png" alt="Cover art of the Star Trek novel &#34;Crisis on Centaurus&#34; by Brad Ferguson. Kirk is pictured on the right, and Spock on the left. In the center is Joanna McCoy wearing a green shirt with something on it I can&#39;t quite make out; possibly the top of a tree. In the background is a structure of some kind engulfed in flame. The tag line reads &#34;Enterprise to the Rescue! Kirk must save both a planet and McCoy&#39;s Daughter!&#34;
"></p>

<p>The story opens at New Athens Spaceport on the Federation colony of Centaurus in the Alpha Centauri system. We get an image of a busy travel hub with somewhat anachronistic product placement, which immediately brings to mind the famous &#39;soup&#39; debacle. My copy is First Edition, but it was printed in Canada, so if someone with access to an American printing wants to check if they see blatant mentions of brand names like American Express or Coca-Cola, or if that was something that got added by a sneaky printer. Memory Beta mentions them, so I suppose it&#39;s in the original manuscript. There are a few oblique references like this lightly peppered throughout. Sears Robuck gets a shoutout later in the book too. Which is a corporation that no longer exists IRL. But this is about as intrusive as they get.</p>



<p>Remember traveler&#39;s cheques? If you&#39;re on the Gen X side of the Xennial spectrum like me, you might remember them as things your parents might use on vacation, or that you&#39;d see commercials for, but that few if any of us ever had a chance to actually use before electronic payment became a thing. This is relevant because the story begins with a Telarite getting angry at an American Express ATM that took his card when he tried to buy some traveler&#39;s cheques, and wouldn&#39;t give it back. If American Express paid for this product placement, the joke is on them with the banter that follows the destruction of the machine.</p>

<p>The police investigating this disturbance notice a man sitting nearby with a box. The first cop questions him, and is about to move on when his partner recognizes him as a local hate monger, wanted criminal, and all around piece of shit Isidore Holtzman. As they&#39;re about to bring him into custody, whatever Holtzman is carrying in the box blows up. The spaceport and much of the city are destroyed.</p>

<p>Meanwhile, on Enterprise, all hell is breaking loose. A critical computer failure causes multiple systems to go offline, including artificial gravity. They manage to get back into normal working order and are planning to set out for Starbase 7 for repairs, when they receive the news of Centaurus, and are diverted to render aid. There&#39;s still no official word on casualties, as the disaster is still unfolding, but there are several on the crew with families on Centaurus, some who might have been at New Athans at the time of the explosion, including Bones&#39; daughter, Joanna McCoy, who was a medical student at New Athens. Her fate is still unknown.</p>

<p>There&#39;s a flashback, where we get a glimpse of Kirk and McCoy&#39;s first meeting 12 years prior, when then-lieutenant Kirk is injured in combat aboard the Farragut, and McCoy oversees his rehabilitation. Near the end of his medical leave, they take a trip together to Centaurus, and meet McCoy&#39;s family, including Joanna, who was a child back then. Kirk makes a claim to a spot of land outside of New Athens.</p>

<p>Back from the flashback, Enterprise arrives at Centaurus, and finds they&#39;re unable to approach the planet because the planet&#39;s defense system is indiscriminately targeting every ship that approaches, and is believed responsible for the destruction of hospital and relief ships that were due to arrive ahead of Enterprise. Enterprise tanks a nuke, and manages to contact the acting president.</p>

<p>Transporters are offline, as the Enterprise is still crippled by computer failure. And the system is flooded by tachyon radiation from the explosion, so they wouldn&#39;t be a good idea anyway. So Kirk, Sulu, and their party take Galileo to meet up with the planetary government, while Spock, Chekov, and their party take Copernicus to the planetary defense center to see if they can shut down the missile defense system.</p>

<p>Uhura takes command for the first time, if you don&#39;t count novels that hadn&#39;t been written yet. And the novel makes a point to call this out. She&#39;s arguably had the conn several times. You could say it&#39;s her first time in command during a crisis, but she commanded the ship during the battle of Starbase 12 in the “Errand of Fury” series, and single-handedly commanded from Auxiliary Control during “A Choice of Catastrophes”, both of which were set before this. And while she did take command in an episode of TAS, that event was set in-universe after the novel, which was printed later. So this is the first time Uhura took command in print after already but not yet taking command a year from now. Yes, I&#39;m trying to deliberately mangle that to be funny. But this is probably the first time she would have taken command chronologically at time of printing. Unless I&#39;m forgetting any. So it&#39;s not incorrect.</p>

<p>It&#39;s revealed that a fringe political movement called the League for a Pure Humanity is responsible for the explosion. This group wants to expel all non-human aliens from Centaurus. You know; racists. And they&#39;re not just your garden variety “speciest against fictional aliens as allegory” racists. They&#39;re actual white supremacists. They&#39;ll tolerate non-white humans to a point, if it suits their short-term purpose. But much like racists in real life, if you think you can trust them because they&#39;re not currently targeting you, you&#39;re a rube. If you&#39;re a member of a historically targeted demographic that they seem to momentarily tolerate while they target someone else, they would eventually turn on you too if they get the chance. Real pieces of shit.</p>

<p>The main tension of the novel is a jurisdiction issue between Centaurus and the Federation. The leader of the “League”, Isidore Holtzman, and many other high-leadership figures died in the explosion. But the remaining LPH leadership figures are still in the wind. Terrorist murder is a capital offense on Centaurus, and the acting Minister of Security Nathaniel Burke wants them to face Centaurian justice, and possibly the death penalty. But because an antimatter device was used in a terrorist attack, the Federation has jurisdiction. And Kirk is under orders to apprehend them and bring them back to Earth for trial.  Federation civilian court has no death penalty, so if convicted in a Federation court, they&#39;ll be sentenced to a cushy rehab colony. So the race is on between Kirk and the local Centaurian authorities to apprehend them first.</p>

<p>Meanwhile, Spock&#39;s party manages to shut down the defense system so that ships can approach the system again, and sets out in search of survivors. They find a makeshift settlement of survivors, and begin the process of supplying aid.</p>

<p>For a novel about a disaster response, I figured there&#39;d be a bit more urgency in responding to disaster. Kirk&#39;s party spends a night at a hotel in McIverson, another town some distance away. Sulu even manages to spend a night on the town, and the nightlife is described as a town going about their lives as though the capital city of their colony wasn&#39;t rendered a smoking crater less than a week ago. Spock and Chekov&#39;s party, after shutting down the defense system, spend a night camping out before setting out the next day on a search for survivors. The local government is so inept that the author feels it necessary to address in the epilogue.</p>

<p>The book was released in 1986, well before 9/11. But 9/11 is probably one of the more prominent events that many of us in the west, particularly in the US or Canada could relate to, and more likely to draw comparison. And as someone who remembers 9/11, many of us were in shock for well over a week, and the effort on the ground was around the clock.  A novel like this has to hit different after 2001 than it would have before. So that kindof lead me to feel that the tone of the novel was a bit off. Though granted, for my generation and younger, it often feels like we&#39;ve been living a prolonged series of disasters ever since. Many of them inflicted upon us by our own governments and their corporate overlords. So in that sense; well played, novel. Well played.</p>

<p>My guess is the author felt that other plot lines were more interesting than a prolonged disaster response sequence. And narratively, it was a good choice, and the novel is better for it. But it makes that aspect conspicuous by its absence.</p>

<p>There are a more than few vestigial remains of a different novel that was planned, but then decidedly changed in the process. And I don&#39;t disagree. Some of those threads probably weren&#39;t going to go where they wanted them to, and had to be tied off.</p>

<p>When we last saw Joanna McCoy chronologically in-universe, it was in the Star Trek Legacies novel “Best Defense”. Another novel that hadn&#39;t been written yet. There, she is a smart, and capable medical student who keeps getting taken hostage, but doesn&#39;t fold into the damsel role easily. She&#39;s an active participant in the plot. If you want to get to know her better, I&#39;d suggest that novel over this one. In this one, she&#39;s a little busy, providing medical assistance to the wounded at the recovery center. If she were a real person, who could blame her? But she&#39;s not a real person. She&#39;s a fictional character who we&#39;re supposed to care about, and not just vicariously though McCoy. Who also doesn&#39;t heavily feature in ⅔ of the novel. She&#39;s still smart. Still capable. Just… you know… kinda busy. So we get Kirk and McCoy&#39;s relief on finding her alive, but not much more than that.</p>

<p>Plot points that do get explored are still engaging. I could nitpick them to death, if I wanted to dwell on it, but I&#39;ve been procrastinating this entry enough as it is. There&#39;s the theme of justice versus revenge; Should the surviving LPH members be executed by the state for the murder of millions? Or is it right that they be sentenced to a soft life on a Federation penal colony, even if it&#39;s a life sentence? Is the death sentence justice, or just revenge? It&#39;s a tension that doesn&#39;t get answered easily, and is ultimately left up to the reader. And I suppose that&#39;s the right choice. There&#39;s not supposed to be an easy answer; just a scenario to consider.</p>

<p><a href="/social-media-book-report/tag:StarTrek" class="hashtag" rel="nofollow"><span>#</span><span class="p-category">StarTrek</span></a></p>
]]></content:encoded>
      <guid>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/crisis-on-centaurus-by-brad-ferguson</guid>
      <pubDate>Sat, 14 Nov 2026 16:37:11 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title>&#34;In Tempest&#39;s Wake&#34; by Dayton Ward.</title>
      <link>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/in-tempests-wake-by-dayton-ward</link>
      <description>&lt;![CDATA[Finished &#34;In Tempest&#39;s Wake&#34; by Dayton Ward.&#xA;&#xA;img src=&#34;https://pixelfed.social/storage/m/_v2/860925387620473976/0e0206425-c6ee71/MpY3MzzqlH3v/4ujUmPNa4JDCEsnscMgkZ8rbKvI4XSWFJq3huV3z.png&#34; alt=&#34;Cover art of the Star Trek Vanguard novel &amp;quot;In Tempest&amp;#39;s Wake&amp;quot; by Dayton Ward. The Watchtower class space station is seen with a white nebula in the backdrop. A Constitution class starship, possibly Enterprise, is in the foreground.&#34;&#xA;&#xA;Following the Battle of Vanguard between Starfleet and the Tholians, Enterprise, Endeavor, and Sagittarius undergo repairs, while Nogura debriefs Kirk on his involvement in the events leading up to the final battle, and the battle itself.&#xA;&#xA;It&#39;s brief, but seems largely unnecessary, as it reads a lot like deleted scenes from the previous novel, held together with a frame plot. We get a little bit more context around how much Kirk and his crew knew about Vanguard. But there&#39;s not much we the audience didn&#39;t already know.&#xA;&#xA;There&#39;s some interpersonal exchange between Kirk and Nogura. Nogura will go on to be Starfleet CnC during the events of &#34;The Motion Picture&#34;, though he&#39;ll be mentioned in dialog only, with a few appearances in beta cannon that I suppose I&#39;ll get to later. In and of itself, that much is fine. But still doesn&#39;t really give any new information.&#xA;&#xA;According to the acknowledgements, Pocketbooks requested this coda. I&#39;m not sure what they felt was missing, except maybe some continuity housekeeping, which often feels tacky to me. And for a novel series centering around covert operations, I think those expectations had already been established. It&#39;s not like Discovery, with all the &#34;oh, half the viewership are bitching about continuity, so let&#39;s burry the whole thing a thousand years into the future and make it all classified&#34; bullshit. It was already classified. So why do we have to classify it again? Just to make it double super-duper classified? But the author said he had fun writing it, and it&#39;s a pretty good recap of the final events of the series.&#xA;&#xA;Anyway, it was fine. I guess you could call it &#34;if novels could have DVD Extras&#34;&#xA;&#xA;#StarTrek #StarTrekVanguard]]&gt;</description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Finished “In Tempest&#39;s Wake” by Dayton Ward.</p>

<p><img src="https://pixelfed.social/storage/m/_v2/860925387620473976/0e0206425-c6ee71/MpY3MzzqlH3v/4ujUmPNa4JDCEsnscMgkZ8rbKvI4XSWFJq3huV3z.png" alt="Cover art of the Star Trek Vanguard novel &#34;In Tempest&#39;s Wake&#34; by Dayton Ward. The Watchtower class space station is seen with a white nebula in the backdrop. A Constitution class starship, possibly Enterprise, is in the foreground."></p>

<p>Following the Battle of Vanguard between Starfleet and the Tholians, Enterprise, Endeavor, and Sagittarius undergo repairs, while Nogura debriefs Kirk on his involvement in the events leading up to the final battle, and the battle itself.</p>

<p>It&#39;s brief, but seems largely unnecessary, as it reads a lot like deleted scenes from the previous novel, held together with a frame plot. We get a little bit more context around how much Kirk and his crew knew about Vanguard. But there&#39;s not much we the audience didn&#39;t already know.</p>

<p>There&#39;s some interpersonal exchange between Kirk and Nogura. Nogura will go on to be Starfleet CnC during the events of “The Motion Picture”, though he&#39;ll be mentioned in dialog only, with a few appearances in beta cannon that I suppose I&#39;ll get to later. In and of itself, that much is fine. But still doesn&#39;t really give any new information.</p>

<p>According to the acknowledgements, Pocketbooks requested this coda. I&#39;m not sure what they felt was missing, except maybe some continuity housekeeping, which often feels tacky to me. And for a novel series centering around covert operations, I think those expectations had already been established. It&#39;s not like Discovery, with all the “oh, half the viewership are bitching about continuity, so let&#39;s burry the whole thing a thousand years into the future and make it all classified” bullshit. It was already classified. So why do we have to classify it again? Just to make it double super-duper classified? But the author said he had fun writing it, and it&#39;s a pretty good recap of the final events of the series.</p>

<p>Anyway, it was fine. I guess you could call it “if novels could have DVD Extras”</p>

<p><a href="/social-media-book-report/tag:StarTrek" class="hashtag" rel="nofollow"><span>#</span><span class="p-category">StarTrek</span></a> <a href="/social-media-book-report/tag:StarTrekVanguard" class="hashtag" rel="nofollow"><span>#</span><span class="p-category">StarTrekVanguard</span></a></p>
]]></content:encoded>
      <guid>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/in-tempests-wake-by-dayton-ward</guid>
      <pubDate>Sat, 17 Oct 2026 17:04:40 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title>Star Trek: Vanguard &#34;Storming Heaven&#34; by David Mack.</title>
      <link>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/star-trek-vanguard-storming-heaven-by-david-mack</link>
      <description>&lt;![CDATA[Finished Star Trek: Vanguard &#34;Storming Heaven&#34; by David Mack.&#xA;&#xA;Cover art of the Star Trek Vanguard novel &#34;Storming Heaven&#34; by David Mack. Vanguard station is in the background with explosions bursting out of the lower core. Enterprise is in front, and Tholian ships swarm all around. Stray phaser beams streak across the lower left and upper right.&#xA;&#xA;Freshly escaped from the T&#39;Kon crystal, the Wanderer regains her strength and rallies the other Shedai to attack Vanguard.&#xA;&#xA;Meanwhile, Nogura and T&#39;Prynn, having traced the source of the artifacts back to the Eremar pulsar, need to send the Sagittarius out to investigate. But the Klingons and Romulans are waiting for them to do just that.&#xA;&#xA;!--more--&#xA;&#xA;And to cap it all off, the Tholians start amassing an armada on the boarder.&#xA;&#xA;T&#39;Prynn comes up with a plan to send a decoy out, which the Klingons and/or Romulans will happily destroy, while the real Sagittarius is deployed from the cargo hold of a freighter at another location.&#xA;&#xA;The decoy is destroyed by Romulans, and Endeavour pretends to investigate and gather the wreckage. The Klingons, believing the Sagittarius is destroyed and the Endeavour is busy, think they can get away with harassing freighters again, so they go after the one carrying Sagittarius. But Nogura anticipated this, and has the Enterprise lying in wait to protect the freighter. Everything seems to be going more or less according to plan. Which is how you know it&#39;s about to go tits up.&#xA;&#xA;Sagittarius makes it to Eremar, and discovers a the ruins of a Dyson bubble in orbit around the pulsar. Not a full sphere, but a series of platforms; staties holding position around the star, and connected by energy lines. They touch down on one, and discover an array of crystals similar to the Mirdonyae artifact, and begin gathering them.&#xA;&#xA;This gets the Tholian&#39;s attention, so a bunch of ships break formation from the armada for Eremar. Endeavor follows, and meets the Tholians at Eremar, but are unable to talk them down before the Tholians start destroying the remains of the Dyson bubble. Endeavor engages with the Tholians, giving Sagittarius time to escape the statite before the Tholians turn it to slag, and they both take off toward Vanguard with the Tholians in hot pursuit. Enterprise arrives en-route to shoo the Tholians off, and Endeavor and Sagittarius are able to make their way back to Vanguard. Though the Enterprise needs to go off and have an episode, so they head out in a different direction.&#xA;&#xA;Back at the station, Carol Marcus and Ming Xiong begin working on how to deploy the T&#39;Kon crystals that Sagittarius brought back. A key element being the equation that the Shedai Apostate gave to Birdy Mac in an earlier novel, but Birdy died before she could bring it back to Starfleet. Quinn saw the formula, but didn&#39;t memorize it, and spent the intervening months trying to wash away the whole ordeal with whiskey. T&#39;Prinn manages to get the information by mind melding with him, and in the process helps him back on the wagon.&#xA;&#xA;Xiong and Marcus are able to complete the array, and use it to capture all of the Shedai. Everything seems to be going more or less according to plan. Which is how you know it&#39;s about to go tits up.&#xA;&#xA;With the Shedai captured and imprisoned in the array, you&#39;d think the whole ordeal would be over. A major threat has been taken off the board. The Tholians are a little stirred up, but other than that, the galaxy is at more or less it&#39;s well-known status quo. But Starfleet Command can&#39;t leave well enough alone, and orders Vanguard to see what else the array can do. So against all better judgement, they flip it on again, which causes all Tholians everywhere to collapse and recoil in pain. If they were stirred up before, they&#39;re rightly pissed off now, and the Armada decides it&#39;s time to wipe Vanguard off the map.&#xA;&#xA;...Aaaaand, a battle ensues, which is as good a point as any to leave the rest to spoilers.&#xA;&#xA;Knowledge seems to be a broad theme of the novel, and to a certain extent, to the series as a whole. The pursuit of forbidden knowledge, the applications of knowledge, the suppression and dissemination of knowledge. The various powers trying to gain what knowledge they can, while denying it to the others. The Klingons because they want to make a weapon of it before someone else does, Starfleet because there could be any number or applications aside from weapons, and it would be best kept from the Klingons or Romulans, and the Tholians who know all to well what the humanoids are dealing with but can&#39;t be arsed to elaborate beyond &#34;you don&#39;t know what you&#39;re dealing with&#34;. In another subplot that I didn&#39;t include in the recap, Duras is getting a little too cozy with the Chancellor, so Jetanien and Lugok give Pennington just enough knowledge to drop a truth bomb on the empire, disrupting Duras&#39; ascension in Klingon politics, and probably sewing the seeds of distrust that will eventually lead to the end of their alliance with the Romulans. These subtle manipulations of information weave threads through the whole tapestry, which inevitably comes unraveled when one is pulled too far.&#xA;&#xA;The buildup with the Shedai seemed to be a damp squib, as Xiong was able to round them all up with the T&#39;kon crystals and a little bit of technobabble. Once the Shedai were captured, the novel pivots to make the Tholians the primary threat. Having a threat neutralized and under thumb is one thing, but we&#39;d expect our heroes at this point to say &#34;Great! Now let&#39;s see if we can communicate with them, and maybe negotiate.&#34; But Starfleet instead decides to experiment with the technology, which should give any discerning Star Trek reader pause. You would think that imprisoning a sentient species, enslaving them and using them against their will to power the very array that captured them would be more disturbing than it comes across. Kirk or Picard would throw a revolt before acceding to that, but Nogura reluctantly states his objections on grounds of caution rather than morally, before giving the order. And it only occurs Xiong and Marcus as a possible legal avenue to stop ill-advised experiments, and not as a moral imperative. Star Trek generally makes a bit more hay over that sort of thing.&#xA;&#xA;Which I suppose is just as well that that morally and practically ill-advised experimentation is exactly what leads to the final showdown with the Tholians.&#xA;&#xA;#StarTrek #Vanguard]]&gt;</description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Finished Star Trek: Vanguard “Storming Heaven” by David Mack.</p>

<p><img src="https://pixelfed.social/storage/m/_v2/734502976034227978/0e0206425-c6ee71/INfryRIvkRz5/Tz34EEkt4xS4uzxi37oLphZimABzfXtomf0g6wrf.png" alt="Cover art of the Star Trek Vanguard novel &#34;Storming Heaven&#34; by David Mack. Vanguard station is in the background with explosions bursting out of the lower core. Enterprise is in front, and Tholian ships swarm all around. Stray phaser beams streak across the lower left and upper right."></p>

<p>Freshly escaped from the T&#39;Kon crystal, the Wanderer regains her strength and rallies the other Shedai to attack Vanguard.</p>

<p>Meanwhile, Nogura and T&#39;Prynn, having traced the source of the artifacts back to the Eremar pulsar, need to send the Sagittarius out to investigate. But the Klingons and Romulans are waiting for them to do just that.</p>



<p>And to cap it all off, the Tholians start amassing an armada on the boarder.</p>

<p>T&#39;Prynn comes up with a plan to send a decoy out, which the Klingons and/or Romulans will happily destroy, while the real Sagittarius is deployed from the cargo hold of a freighter at another location.</p>

<p>The decoy is destroyed by Romulans, and Endeavour pretends to investigate and gather the wreckage. The Klingons, believing the Sagittarius is destroyed and the Endeavour is busy, think they can get away with harassing freighters again, so they go after the one carrying Sagittarius. But Nogura anticipated this, and has the Enterprise lying in wait to protect the freighter. Everything seems to be going more or less according to plan. Which is how you know it&#39;s about to go tits up.</p>

<p>Sagittarius makes it to Eremar, and discovers a the ruins of a Dyson bubble in orbit around the pulsar. Not a full sphere, but a series of platforms; staties holding position around the star, and connected by energy lines. They touch down on one, and discover an array of crystals similar to the Mirdonyae artifact, and begin gathering them.</p>

<p>This gets the Tholian&#39;s attention, so a bunch of ships break formation from the armada for Eremar. Endeavor follows, and meets the Tholians at Eremar, but are unable to talk them down before the Tholians start destroying the remains of the Dyson bubble. Endeavor engages with the Tholians, giving Sagittarius time to escape the statite before the Tholians turn it to slag, and they both take off toward Vanguard with the Tholians in hot pursuit. Enterprise arrives en-route to shoo the Tholians off, and Endeavor and Sagittarius are able to make their way back to Vanguard. Though the Enterprise needs to go off and have an episode, so they head out in a different direction.</p>

<p>Back at the station, Carol Marcus and Ming Xiong begin working on how to deploy the T&#39;Kon crystals that Sagittarius brought back. A key element being the equation that the Shedai Apostate gave to Birdy Mac in an earlier novel, but Birdy died before she could bring it back to Starfleet. Quinn saw the formula, but didn&#39;t memorize it, and spent the intervening months trying to wash away the whole ordeal with whiskey. T&#39;Prinn manages to get the information by mind melding with him, and in the process helps him back on the wagon.</p>

<p>Xiong and Marcus are able to complete the array, and use it to capture all of the Shedai. Everything seems to be going more or less according to plan. Which is how you know it&#39;s about to go tits up.</p>

<p>With the Shedai captured and imprisoned in the array, you&#39;d think the whole ordeal would be over. A major threat has been taken off the board. The Tholians are a little stirred up, but other than that, the galaxy is at more or less it&#39;s well-known status quo. But Starfleet Command can&#39;t leave well enough alone, and orders Vanguard to see what else the array can do. So against all better judgement, they flip it on again, which causes all Tholians everywhere to collapse and recoil in pain. If they were stirred up before, they&#39;re rightly pissed off now, and the Armada decides it&#39;s time to wipe Vanguard off the map.</p>

<p>...Aaaaand, a battle ensues, which is as good a point as any to leave the rest to spoilers.</p>

<p>Knowledge seems to be a broad theme of the novel, and to a certain extent, to the series as a whole. The pursuit of forbidden knowledge, the applications of knowledge, the suppression and dissemination of knowledge. The various powers trying to gain what knowledge they can, while denying it to the others. The Klingons because they want to make a weapon of it before someone else does, Starfleet because there could be any number or applications aside from weapons, and it would be best kept from the Klingons or Romulans, and the Tholians who know all to well what the humanoids are dealing with but can&#39;t be arsed to elaborate beyond “you don&#39;t know what you&#39;re dealing with”. In another subplot that I didn&#39;t include in the recap, Duras is getting a little too cozy with the Chancellor, so Jetanien and Lugok give Pennington just enough knowledge to drop a truth bomb on the empire, disrupting Duras&#39; ascension in Klingon politics, and probably sewing the seeds of distrust that will eventually lead to the end of their alliance with the Romulans. These subtle manipulations of information weave threads through the whole tapestry, which inevitably comes unraveled when one is pulled too far.</p>

<p>The buildup with the Shedai seemed to be a damp squib, as Xiong was able to round them all up with the T&#39;kon crystals and a little bit of technobabble. Once the Shedai were captured, the novel pivots to make the Tholians the primary threat. Having a threat neutralized and under thumb is one thing, but we&#39;d expect our heroes at this point to say “Great! Now let&#39;s see if we can communicate with them, and maybe negotiate.” But Starfleet instead decides to experiment with the technology, which should give any discerning Star Trek reader pause. You would think that imprisoning a sentient species, enslaving them and using them against their will to power the very array that captured them would be more disturbing than it comes across. Kirk or Picard would throw a revolt before acceding to that, but Nogura reluctantly states his objections on grounds of caution rather than morally, before giving the order. And it only occurs Xiong and Marcus as a possible legal avenue to stop ill-advised experiments, and not as a moral imperative. Star Trek generally makes a bit more hay over that sort of thing.</p>

<p>Which I suppose is just as well that that morally and practically ill-advised experimentation is exactly what leads to the final showdown with the Tholians.</p>

<p><a href="/social-media-book-report/tag:StarTrek" class="hashtag" rel="nofollow"><span>#</span><span class="p-category">StarTrek</span></a> <a href="/social-media-book-report/tag:Vanguard" class="hashtag" rel="nofollow"><span>#</span><span class="p-category">Vanguard</span></a></p>
]]></content:encoded>
      <guid>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/star-trek-vanguard-storming-heaven-by-david-mack</guid>
      <pubDate>Thu, 15 Oct 2026 19:09:01 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title>&#34;Sanctuary&#34; by John Vornholt.</title>
      <link>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/sanctuary-by-john-vornholt</link>
      <description>&lt;![CDATA[Finished &#34;Sanctuary&#34; by John Vornholt.&#xA;&#xA;![Cover art of the Star Trek novel &#34;Sanctuary&#34; by John Vornholt. Kirk and Spock are pictured in the foreground. Spock has a tricorder strap over his shoulder. In the background is an orange planet circled by electrical arcs on a redish orange background. The tagline reads &#34;Kirk, Spock, and McCoy are trapped on a planet from which there is no escape!&#34;&#xA;](https://pixelfed.social/storage/m/_v2/734502976034227978/0e0206425-c6ee71/TFa3scHX12Uw/PRVVAocwWy86jzv5SUtPUI08SJ2BNfQoyIi5dJXU.png)&#xA;&#xA;The novel opens with Enterprise in hot pursuit of infamous pirate Auk-Rex. Auk-Rex is kindof a Dread Pirate Roberts; more of a persona than a person, probably an alias, and mostly serves as a plot justification for the rest of the novel. Auk-Rex is bookin&#39; it to an uncharted planet, which Spock hastily speculates might be a place called &#34;Sanctuary&#34;. A place Starfleet only knows about by rumor where fugitives and political dissidents often go to escape pursuit. So Auk-Rex will be home free if the ship is able to make it there.&#xA;&#xA;!--more--&#xA;&#xA;They concoct a plan to launch a shuttle to pursue Auk-Rex as they&#39;re expected to catch up just as they reach orbit. So Kirk, Spock, and McCoy depart in the shuttle, and pursue Auk-Rex&#39;s ship down to the surface only to witness an escape pod crash into the mountain as they arrive.&#xA;&#xA;Now on the ground, they are basically mugged by forest dwelling bandits of various races who relive them of most of their useful technology. They make it back to the landing site only to find that their shuttle is gone; transported away by the Senites.&#xA;&#xA;One of the Senites, Zicree introduces themself and welcomes them, explaining that anyone who comes to Sanctuary is welcome, but must set their old lives behind them, and are never permitted to leave.&#xA;&#xA;The Senites are a race of genderless aliens native to sanctuary. This isn&#39;t a major theme or anything. They just are.&#xA;&#xA;Now… this novel was released in 1992, about 6 months after the TNG Episode &#34;The Outcast&#34;, and was probably being written over the previous year. And while non-binary and gender nonconforming people have existed for as long as there have been people, back in the &#39;90s, they weren&#39;t really at the forefront of public consciousness. Workshopping of English neopronouns was mostly just beginning, and we were still years away from collectively settling on singular they/them.  Star Trek novels did contribute somewhat to this workshopping, with the Hermats, aliens possessing of both genders preferring s\he (which I sort of read in my head back then as sh-he) and hir. But we won&#39;t encounter them until later. So the pronoun the Senites got stuck with was unfortunately &#39;it&#39;, though the occasional &#39;he&#39; slipped in. But they don&#39;t really complain about it, and it doesn&#39;t really come up all that much, so opinions may vary on how much that really matters.&#xA;&#xA;Anyway, so the Senites allow outcasts, fugitives, refugees, dissidents, or anyone fleeing persecution to come to Santuary to live out their lives. And if they can make it to the ground, then they are free to stay. But they are basically imprisoned there, prevented from ever leaving by the Senites themselves, who impound spacecraft, and maintain an energy shield around the planet. Kirk and party try to explain that they didn&#39;t know that before they came down, but Zicree isn&#39;t hearing it.&#xA;&#xA;Kirk, Spock and McCoy eventually make their way to a nearby settlement of Dohama, briefly encountering a couple remote homesteading communities on the way. Dohama is inhabited by some of the more savory fugitives, and the Senites generally keep them placated with booze, greasy foods, and nightly festivities. Not too bad a place if you&#39;re into that sort of thing. There aren&#39;t very many women around, though. It&#39;s rumored most of the women are in another settlement called Khyming, which itself is nearby the Senites&#39; seminary and their main base of operation. They meet Billiwog, a long term resident who likes building boats, and buy a boat from him to try to reach Khyming.&#xA;&#xA;Meanwhile, in orbit, Scotty and the Enterprise learn the nature of Sanctuary from the sundry bounty hunters and rival powers blockading the planet in hopes of catching fleeing fugitives before they make landfall. They meet a Klingon captain who had been stationed there for some years just in case a fugitive from the Klingon Empire comes along that he can catch before they touch down. And an Orion pirate captain and former slave girl who Scotty has a brief dalliance with.&#xA;&#xA;Back on the planet, Kirk and the boys wash up on Khyming. Zicree appears and tells them they can stay, as long as they behave, but if they become a problem, they&#39;ll be sent back to Dohama.&#xA;&#xA;Where Dohama is a rollicking beach-side shanty town, Khyming is more like a resort spa. They meet up with a human woman, Renna, who recently arrived on Sanctuary with her elderly father, who is in the infirmary suffering massive injuries after crashing on the planet. Injuries consistent with an escape pod ejecting too close to the ground. After her father dies, she joins up with Kirk and party in planning their escape from Sanctuary.&#xA;&#xA;I&#39;m going to leave the summary there for the most part; I don&#39;t think it&#39;s necessary to get any further into spoilers. Memory Beta has a more detailed summary, so it&#39;s not like the plot isn&#39;t already out there.&#xA;&#xA;It&#39;s an interesting dynamic; If you were to set up a situation like this, welcoming all comers from all walks of life, including unrepentant criminals, you&#39;ll inevitably end up needing to keep the more well behaved residents sequestered from the rifraf. So it makes sense that you&#39;d have an isolated place like Khyming, and that Khyming would be majority female. And that much of the majority male criminal element would be exiled to the mainland in a place like Dohama. It&#39;s clear the author put some thought into how this situation would pan out. I mean let&#39;s face it; There&#39;s a reason the hypothetical of meeting a bear in the woods exists. I&#39;m a straight-passing cis male, and some days, given the choice, I&#39;d choose the bear too. It&#39;s not the main theme, but it is a theme that gets some exploration.&#xA;&#xA;Another theme that gets touched on, but doesn&#39;t get nearly as much attention comes with the revelation that the Senites reproduce by periodically drugging the denizens of places like Dohama and surgically altering and mentally conditioning them. This is posited as more of a situation that poses a hazard for our heroes and their rag-tag party of refugees to escape from, more than saying anything about bodily autonomy, or forced indoctrination.&#xA;&#xA;Starfleet sends the USS Neptune to assist Scotty with trying to retrieve their missing crewmates, which also makes an interesting side quest. The Neptune is a science ship specializing in marine biology, and Scotty was previously acquainted with the captain, Donald Mora. They can&#39;t beam down any technology, because it will be destroyed or confiscated by the Senites. They can only beam down biological matter, but anyone they beam down won&#39;t be able to leave. This leads Captain Mora to one of the more creative solutions I&#39;ve seen from a Starfleet captain; to beam down a plague of Regulan locusts that he happens to have aboard that have been irradiated so they don&#39;t reproduce and become invasive, but that the Senites won&#39;t soon forget. Quite refreshing for anyone who whishes Starfleet would show more balls in dealing with situations sometimes.&#xA;&#xA;The main theme according to the author in his forward to the novel is spaceflight being a privilege. Which yeah, is in there. Kirk and party, and anyone else whether they came to Sanctuary of their own volition or not are planetbound against their will, and denied any conveyance that could return them to the ship.&#xA;&#xA;The much more interesting journey follows Kirk and party across Santuary, from Dohama to Khyming and onward, while they try to devise some way to circumvent the Senites&#39; security system and leave the planet. It&#39;s really about the journey rather than the destination. And the real treasure are the friends we maroon on a prison cult planet along the way.&#xA;&#xA;StarTrek&#xA;]]&gt;</description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Finished “Sanctuary” by John Vornholt.</p>

<p><img src="https://pixelfed.social/storage/m/_v2/734502976034227978/0e0206425-c6ee71/TFa3scHX12Uw/PRVVAocwWy86jzv5SUtPUI08SJ2BNfQoyIi5dJXU.png" alt="Cover art of the Star Trek novel &#34;Sanctuary&#34; by John Vornholt. Kirk and Spock are pictured in the foreground. Spock has a tricorder strap over his shoulder. In the background is an orange planet circled by electrical arcs on a redish orange background. The tagline reads &#34;Kirk, Spock, and McCoy are trapped on a planet from which there is no escape!&#34;
"></p>

<p>The novel opens with Enterprise in hot pursuit of infamous pirate Auk-Rex. Auk-Rex is kindof a Dread Pirate Roberts; more of a persona than a person, probably an alias, and mostly serves as a plot justification for the rest of the novel. Auk-Rex is bookin&#39; it to an uncharted planet, which Spock hastily speculates might be a place called “Sanctuary”. A place Starfleet only knows about by rumor where fugitives and political dissidents often go to escape pursuit. So Auk-Rex will be home free if the ship is able to make it there.</p>



<p>They concoct a plan to launch a shuttle to pursue Auk-Rex as they&#39;re expected to catch up just as they reach orbit. So Kirk, Spock, and McCoy depart in the shuttle, and pursue Auk-Rex&#39;s ship down to the surface only to witness an escape pod crash into the mountain as they arrive.</p>

<p>Now on the ground, they are basically mugged by forest dwelling bandits of various races who relive them of most of their useful technology. They make it back to the landing site only to find that their shuttle is gone; transported away by the Senites.</p>

<p>One of the Senites, Zicree introduces themself and welcomes them, explaining that anyone who comes to Sanctuary is welcome, but must set their old lives behind them, and are never permitted to leave.</p>

<p>The Senites are a race of genderless aliens native to sanctuary. This isn&#39;t a major theme or anything. They just are.</p>

<p>Now… this novel was released in 1992, about 6 months after the TNG Episode “The Outcast”, and was probably being written over the previous year. And while non-binary and gender nonconforming people have existed for as long as there have been people, back in the &#39;90s, they weren&#39;t really at the forefront of public consciousness. Workshopping of English neopronouns was mostly just beginning, and we were still years away from collectively settling on singular they/them.  Star Trek novels did contribute somewhat to this workshopping, with the Hermats, aliens possessing of both genders preferring s\he (which I sort of read in my head back then as sh-he) and hir. But we won&#39;t encounter them until later. So the pronoun the Senites got stuck with was unfortunately &#39;it&#39;, though the occasional &#39;he&#39; slipped in. But they don&#39;t really complain about it, and it doesn&#39;t really come up all that much, so opinions may vary on how much that really matters.</p>

<p>Anyway, so the Senites allow outcasts, fugitives, refugees, dissidents, or anyone fleeing persecution to come to Santuary to live out their lives. And if they can make it to the ground, then they are free to stay. But they are basically imprisoned there, prevented from ever leaving by the Senites themselves, who impound spacecraft, and maintain an energy shield around the planet. Kirk and party try to explain that they didn&#39;t know that before they came down, but Zicree isn&#39;t hearing it.</p>

<p>Kirk, Spock and McCoy eventually make their way to a nearby settlement of Dohama, briefly encountering a couple remote homesteading communities on the way. Dohama is inhabited by some of the more savory fugitives, and the Senites generally keep them placated with booze, greasy foods, and nightly festivities. Not too bad a place if you&#39;re into that sort of thing. There aren&#39;t very many women around, though. It&#39;s rumored most of the women are in another settlement called Khyming, which itself is nearby the Senites&#39; seminary and their main base of operation. They meet Billiwog, a long term resident who likes building boats, and buy a boat from him to try to reach Khyming.</p>

<p>Meanwhile, in orbit, Scotty and the Enterprise learn the nature of Sanctuary from the sundry bounty hunters and rival powers blockading the planet in hopes of catching fleeing fugitives before they make landfall. They meet a Klingon captain who had been stationed there for some years just in case a fugitive from the Klingon Empire comes along that he can catch before they touch down. And an Orion pirate captain and former slave girl who Scotty has a brief dalliance with.</p>

<p>Back on the planet, Kirk and the boys wash up on Khyming. Zicree appears and tells them they can stay, as long as they behave, but if they become a problem, they&#39;ll be sent back to Dohama.</p>

<p>Where Dohama is a rollicking beach-side shanty town, Khyming is more like a resort spa. They meet up with a human woman, Renna, who recently arrived on Sanctuary with her elderly father, who is in the infirmary suffering massive injuries after crashing on the planet. Injuries consistent with an escape pod ejecting too close to the ground. After her father dies, she joins up with Kirk and party in planning their escape from Sanctuary.</p>

<p>I&#39;m going to leave the summary there for the most part; I don&#39;t think it&#39;s necessary to get any further into spoilers. Memory Beta has a more detailed summary, so it&#39;s not like the plot isn&#39;t already out there.</p>

<p>It&#39;s an interesting dynamic; If you were to set up a situation like this, welcoming all comers from all walks of life, including unrepentant criminals, you&#39;ll inevitably end up needing to keep the more well behaved residents sequestered from the rifraf. So it makes sense that you&#39;d have an isolated place like Khyming, and that Khyming would be majority female. And that much of the majority male criminal element would be exiled to the mainland in a place like Dohama. It&#39;s clear the author put some thought into how this situation would pan out. I mean let&#39;s face it; There&#39;s a reason the hypothetical of meeting a bear in the woods exists. I&#39;m a straight-passing cis male, and some days, given the choice, I&#39;d choose the bear too. It&#39;s not the main theme, but it is a theme that gets some exploration.</p>

<p>Another theme that gets touched on, but doesn&#39;t get nearly as much attention comes with the revelation that the Senites reproduce by periodically drugging the denizens of places like Dohama and surgically altering and mentally conditioning them. This is posited as more of a situation that poses a hazard for our heroes and their rag-tag party of refugees to escape from, more than saying anything about bodily autonomy, or forced indoctrination.</p>

<p>Starfleet sends the USS Neptune to assist Scotty with trying to retrieve their missing crewmates, which also makes an interesting side quest. The Neptune is a science ship specializing in marine biology, and Scotty was previously acquainted with the captain, Donald Mora. They can&#39;t beam down any technology, because it will be destroyed or confiscated by the Senites. They can only beam down biological matter, but anyone they beam down won&#39;t be able to leave. This leads Captain Mora to one of the more creative solutions I&#39;ve seen from a Starfleet captain; to beam down a plague of Regulan locusts that he happens to have aboard that have been irradiated so they don&#39;t reproduce and become invasive, but that the Senites won&#39;t soon forget. Quite refreshing for anyone who whishes Starfleet would show more balls in dealing with situations sometimes.</p>

<p>The main theme according to the author in his forward to the novel is spaceflight being a privilege. Which yeah, is in there. Kirk and party, and anyone else whether they came to Sanctuary of their own volition or not are planetbound against their will, and denied any conveyance that could return them to the ship.</p>

<p>The much more interesting journey follows Kirk and party across Santuary, from Dohama to Khyming and onward, while they try to devise some way to circumvent the Senites&#39; security system and leave the planet. It&#39;s really about the journey rather than the destination. And the real treasure are the friends we maroon on a prison cult planet along the way.</p>

<p><a href="/social-media-book-report/tag:StarTrek" class="hashtag" rel="nofollow"><span>#</span><span class="p-category">StarTrek</span></a></p>
]]></content:encoded>
      <guid>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/sanctuary-by-john-vornholt</guid>
      <pubDate>Thu, 15 Oct 2026 19:03:53 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title>&#34;Mudd in Your Eye&#34; by Jerry Oltion.</title>
      <link>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/mudd-in-your-eye-by-jerry-oltion</link>
      <description>&lt;![CDATA[Finished &#34;Mudd in Your Eye&#34; by Jerry Oltion.&#xA;&#xA;Cover art of the Star Trek novel &#34;Mudd in Your Eye&#34; by Jerry Oltion. Mudd is pictured in the background from the neck up looking smugly up to the left. Kirk stands crossarmed looking toward the viewer. Enterprise is seen swooping below. The backdrop looks like a dark side of a planet outlined in redish orange orbiting a much larger dark sphere. The tagline reads &#34;The only man who can end an interplanetary war is… Harry Mudd?&#34;&#xA;&#xA;The novel opens with Kirk presiding over the wedding of two crew members, Simon Nordell from Engineering, and Leslie Lebrun from Security. A couple apparently in love, despite their constant bickering. &#xA;&#xA;Symbolism!&#xA;&#xA;After the wedding, he receives orders from Starfleet to travel to the Nevis system. The Nevisians have been at war for over 12,000 years. That&#39;s not a typo. They&#39;ve actually been at war that long. They&#39;d begun pushing out into the galaxy doing all the usual spacefaring stuff, exploration, commerce, what have you, until suddenly they were all recalled to their home system, withdrew all their ambassadors, and reverted to isolationism while they persistently fought each other. And suddenly, these cultures who have been at war since humanity first figured out agriculture have declared peace. The Federation is certainly not complaining, but thinks it&#39;s unusual enough that they ought to send a starship over to check it out.&#xA;&#xA;!--more--&#xA;&#xA;The two cultures of the Nevisian system the Distrellians and the Prastorians inhabit 2 different worlds. Enterprise arrives at Distrell, as it&#39;s the first on the way, but Prastorian officials are there too celebrating.&#xA;&#xA;Nevis is home to a rare fruit delicacy called Palko fruit, which consists of purple and white parts. Each has part of a binary neurotoxin. As long as you only eat either the purple or the white part, and not both, you&#39;ll be fine. But they&#39;re deadly if you eat them together. &#xA;&#xA;Symbolism!&#xA;&#xA;Apparently the petty grievance that lead to the Nevisians going to war for 12000 years is who gets to eat the more flavourful purple bits. The solution that lead to their newly found peace was that they both eat the purple bits, and sell the white bits to the galaxy at large. And the entrepreneur who brought them this new marketing opportunity is none other than…(spoiler alert for the guy whose face is on the cover, and also his name in the title…) Harry Mudd!&#xA;&#xA;When we last left Harry Mudd, (Depending on how you feel about the New Visions comic book series (Meh… it&#39;s ok, I guess)) Kirk had exiled him on the android planet with 500 android copies of his estranged wife Stella for company. He escaped his imprisonment by convincing the androids that he&#39;d reformed. That he was ready to be released. And that apparently convinced them enough to parole him, but with one of the Stella androids as chaperone.&#xA;&#xA;Symbolism!&#xA;&#xA;Kirk and Mudd exchange a few barbs, they make a scene, and Kirk and crew are asked to leave the party. So they return to the ship. &#xA;&#xA;Mudd begins skulking about the palace, looking for something to loot, when out of nowhere, hostilities resume. Mudd is caught sneaking around the catacombs, and is presumed to have betrayed Distrell by allowing Prastorian soldiers in. Kirk contacts the Distrellians and while the battle is still raging outside, he learns that Harry has been sentenced to be executed. He offers to beam down and take him into Federation custody instead, and the Distrellians agree. So Kirk beams down with a landing party, including the newlywed Lebrun.&#xA;&#xA;I need to put a 🚨bSPOILER WARNING/b🚨here. By this point the reader has likely figured this part out, but I don&#39;t want to rob anyone of the fun of piecing it together.&#xA;&#xA;When you die on Distrell you respawn on Prastor, and vice versa, and are expected to begin a new life on that world until you are eventually called up to go to battle again. Their prolonged war has been a 12000 year long Call of Duty LARP, and the Nevisians are eager to get back into it.&#xA;&#xA;Lebrun is killed trying to help Mudd escape. Mudd suffers a fatal injury, and eventually dies. Kirk and the rest of the away team return to the ship, not realizing yet that Lebrun and Mudd are still alive on Prastor.&#xA;&#xA;Stella takes off in her ship toward Prastor for some reason, and Kirk goes after her. Chekov, Sulu, Scotty, and Kirk all die trying to retrieve Stella and escape the fighting on Prastor. Stella is beamed back to the Enterprise, and informs Spock that the away team was killed, and Spock is unaware that they&#39;re still alive on Distrell.&#xA;&#xA;🚨Thus endeth the spoiler bit.🚨&#xA;&#xA;So the landing party is separated across the two planets in the middle of a war zone, and need to escape and find their way back to the ship.&#xA;&#xA;It&#39;s a fun story. There&#39;s some standard banter between Kirk and Mudd. The supporting cast gets a little bit more to do than in recent novels. The overarching puzzle isn&#39;t too complex for the reader, but it&#39;s fun watching the characters figure it out.&#xA;&#xA;Mudd gets a bit of character growth. He&#39;s still a scoundrel, but not wholly irredeemable. And is given the opportunity for heroic self-sacrifice.&#xA;&#xA;And a good time was had by all.&#xA;&#xA;startrek]]&gt;</description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Finished “Mudd in Your Eye” by Jerry Oltion.</p>

<p><img src="https://pixelfed.social/storage/m/_v2/860925387620473976/f0975049d-79c41a/tDQg2l27Bl4q/4C2lMoZNGW4vISvIAL5KhCvKmpUj5a9bIlbguk6p.png" alt="Cover art of the Star Trek novel &#34;Mudd in Your Eye&#34; by Jerry Oltion. Mudd is pictured in the background from the neck up looking smugly up to the left. Kirk stands crossarmed looking toward the viewer. Enterprise is seen swooping below. The backdrop looks like a dark side of a planet outlined in redish orange orbiting a much larger dark sphere. The tagline reads &#34;The only man who can end an interplanetary war is… Harry Mudd?&#34;"></p>

<p>The novel opens with Kirk presiding over the wedding of two crew members, Simon Nordell from Engineering, and Leslie Lebrun from Security. A couple apparently in love, despite their constant bickering.</p>

<p>Symbolism!</p>

<p>After the wedding, he receives orders from Starfleet to travel to the Nevis system. The Nevisians have been at war for over 12,000 years. That&#39;s not a typo. They&#39;ve actually been at war that long. They&#39;d begun pushing out into the galaxy doing all the usual spacefaring stuff, exploration, commerce, what have you, until suddenly they were all recalled to their home system, withdrew all their ambassadors, and reverted to isolationism while they persistently fought each other. And suddenly, these cultures who have been at war since humanity first figured out agriculture have declared peace. The Federation is certainly not complaining, but thinks it&#39;s unusual enough that they ought to send a starship over to check it out.</p>



<p>The two cultures of the Nevisian system the Distrellians and the Prastorians inhabit 2 different worlds. Enterprise arrives at Distrell, as it&#39;s the first on the way, but Prastorian officials are there too celebrating.</p>

<p>Nevis is home to a rare fruit delicacy called Palko fruit, which consists of purple and white parts. Each has part of a binary neurotoxin. As long as you only eat either the purple or the white part, and not both, you&#39;ll be fine. But they&#39;re deadly if you eat them together.</p>

<p>Symbolism!</p>

<p>Apparently the petty grievance that lead to the Nevisians going to war for 12000 years is who gets to eat the more flavourful purple bits. The solution that lead to their newly found peace was that they both eat the purple bits, and sell the white bits to the galaxy at large. And the entrepreneur who brought them this new marketing opportunity is none other than…(spoiler alert for the guy whose face is on the cover, and also his name in the title…) Harry Mudd!</p>

<p>When we last left Harry Mudd, (Depending on how you feel about the New Visions comic book series (Meh… it&#39;s ok, I guess)) Kirk had exiled him on the android planet with 500 android copies of his estranged wife Stella for company. He escaped his imprisonment by convincing the androids that he&#39;d reformed. That he was ready to be released. And that apparently convinced them enough to parole him, but with one of the Stella androids as chaperone.</p>

<p>Symbolism!</p>

<p>Kirk and Mudd exchange a few barbs, they make a scene, and Kirk and crew are asked to leave the party. So they return to the ship.</p>

<p>Mudd begins skulking about the palace, looking for something to loot, when out of nowhere, hostilities resume. Mudd is caught sneaking around the catacombs, and is presumed to have betrayed Distrell by allowing Prastorian soldiers in. Kirk contacts the Distrellians and while the battle is still raging outside, he learns that Harry has been sentenced to be executed. He offers to beam down and take him into Federation custody instead, and the Distrellians agree. So Kirk beams down with a landing party, including the newlywed Lebrun.</p>

<p>I need to put a 🚨<b>SPOILER WARNING</b>🚨here. By this point the reader has likely figured this part out, but I don&#39;t want to rob anyone of the fun of piecing it together.</p>

<p>When you die on Distrell you respawn on Prastor, and vice versa, and are expected to begin a new life on that world until you are eventually called up to go to battle again. Their prolonged war has been a 12000 year long Call of Duty LARP, and the Nevisians are eager to get back into it.</p>

<p>Lebrun is killed trying to help Mudd escape. Mudd suffers a fatal injury, and eventually dies. Kirk and the rest of the away team return to the ship, not realizing yet that Lebrun and Mudd are still alive on Prastor.</p>

<p>Stella takes off in her ship toward Prastor for some reason, and Kirk goes after her. Chekov, Sulu, Scotty, and Kirk all die trying to retrieve Stella and escape the fighting on Prastor. Stella is beamed back to the Enterprise, and informs Spock that the away team was killed, and Spock is unaware that they&#39;re still alive on Distrell.</p>

<p>🚨Thus endeth the spoiler bit.🚨</p>

<p>So the landing party is separated across the two planets in the middle of a war zone, and need to escape and find their way back to the ship.</p>

<p>It&#39;s a fun story. There&#39;s some standard banter between Kirk and Mudd. The supporting cast gets a little bit more to do than in recent novels. The overarching puzzle isn&#39;t too complex for the reader, but it&#39;s fun watching the characters figure it out.</p>

<p>Mudd gets a bit of character growth. He&#39;s still a scoundrel, but not wholly irredeemable. And is given the opportunity for heroic self-sacrifice.</p>

<p>And a good time was had by all.</p>

<p><a href="/social-media-book-report/tag:startrek" class="hashtag" rel="nofollow"><span>#</span><span class="p-category">startrek</span></a></p>
]]></content:encoded>
      <guid>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/mudd-in-your-eye-by-jerry-oltion</guid>
      <pubDate>Wed, 16 Sep 2026 01:53:46 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title>&#34;One Small Step&#34; by Susan Wright</title>
      <link>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/one-small-step-by-susan-wright</link>
      <description>&lt;![CDATA[Finished &#34;One Small Step&#34; by Susan Wright.&#xA;&#xA;Cover art of the Star Trek Novel Gateways Book one of Seven, One Small Step by Susan Wright. The cover is framed with an Iconian gateway structure with stylized pillars on the side, rising to an archway across the top. Through the gateway is the Petraw homeworld; a large moon rises over the horizon of a rocky desert landscape with two fortress like structures, one fading to the background, and the other closer to the frame of the gateway.  The tagline reads &#34;The beginning of a cosmic saga that spans the galaxy!&#34;&#xA;&#xA;The story opens toward the end of the episode &#34;That Which Survives&#34;. Kirk, McCoy and Sulu are trapped on the Kalandan station surrounded by the 3 Losira replicants. Spock and a security guard beam down just in time to shoot the Kalandan defense computer and saves them. Kirk hails the ship for beamout, they have a little chat about beauty surviving.&#xA;&#xA;The end.&#xA;&#xA;After the credits, Enterprise tries to beam up the landing party, but the transporter is interrupted by the biofilter detecting the disease that killed off the Kalandans. The entire landing party is infected, and can&#39;t leave until they can find a cure. While they&#39;re working on a cure, they continue to explore the station, discovering the Kalandan living quarters, one of the control rooms, some other interesting things. They&#39;re able to get some computer access, but since the station is in lockdown, all the vital information is controlled by the defense computer, which the security officer, whose name is Reinhart, by the way, left in a smoldering mess.&#xA;&#xA;!--more--&#xA;&#xA;Kirk reaches out to command, explains what they&#39;ve found, and is ordered not to allow the station to fall into enemy hands.&#xA;&#xA;The activation of the Kalandan station yeeting Enterprise 900 lightyears away and Losira&#39;s repeated usage of the portal generates a massive power spike, which gets the attention of a Klingon ship, as well as a Petraw scout ship. The Petraw are a kindof eusocial humanoid species. Their scout ships are crewed by a half dozen or so individuals, who scour the galaxy to obtain interesting technology, which they then send back to their homeworld. To get their hands on alien technology, they often pursue elaborate con jobs. They gather as much information as they can, tapping into Enterprise&#39;s comms with Starfleet Command, and decide to pose as the descendants of the Kalandans to stake claim to the station.&#xA;&#xA;The Klingons arrive first, itching for a fight. Enterprise fights back, but their warp engines are still offline following Losira&#39;s sabotage, so they&#39;re on the ropes. Then the Petraw claiming to be Kalandans arrive, blow the Klingons to scrap, and introduce themselves. And as icing on the cake, they just happen to have a vaccine treatment that will prevent the sporocite infection from becoming a virus, allowing the away team to safely beam back to the ship.&#xA;&#xA;Kirk is naturally suspicious, but has no proof. So he has no choice but to play along diplomatically until he can gather more information. More Klingons will be on their way, but it will take them a few days to get there. He can&#39;t let the station fall into Klingon hands, but he can&#39;t be sure the Kalandans are who they say they are, so he&#39;s unsure if he can allow them to take it either. He agrees to team up with the Kalandans to explore the station and gather more information. The Petraw commander, Tasm, observed Kirk&#39;s attraction to Losira, so she tailored her appearance thinking she could use her feminine wiles to manipulate Kirk. But Kirk finds her advances off-putting.&#xA;&#xA;Their medical officer, Luz, also assumes the form of a beautiful woman, targeting McCoy.&#xA;&#xA;They discover the gateway system that the Losira replicant used to pop in and out of existence. The system that let her instantly appear at any part on the surface of the planet, and even travel to and from Enterprise while it was on its way back from where it was punted. The Petraw want this technology above anything else that might be available on the station. But Kirk recognizes that it can be dangerous in the wrong hands. But anyway, it&#39;s locked out by the defense computer, so they&#39;ve got to get it back into working order before it&#39;ll be of any use to anyone.&#xA;&#xA;It&#39;s an interesting game of cat and mouse. The reader knows the Petraw aren&#39;t really Kalandans. Kirk is suspicious, but not certain. McCoy seems reticent to look a gift horse in the mouth. Especially when one of those gift horses talks the talk of a brilliant medical officer, and is also kinda hot. McCoy more than most of the crew seems to play the mark. Scotty and Spock are seldom in a position to question the Kalandan&#39;s authenticity, and the rest of the crew… well…&#xA;&#xA;One thing I&#39;ve noticed with a few novels lately is the narrative&#39;s tendency to forget that the rest of the crew exist unless they&#39;re needed. Uhura and Chekov in particular are on the bridge, do their jobs when called on, but the narrative doesn&#39;t bring any attention to them unless they&#39;re needed to perform some action to move a particular scene forward. And one gets the impression that if Sulu weren&#39;t on the planet at the end of the episode, the novel would have forgotten about him too, except for a few instances where he needs to take command. The novel tries to give some of the background characters something to do, M&#39;Benga, Rahda, Reinhart, and even some original characters we&#39;ve never seen before. But falls into the common habit of forgetting members of the principle cast.&#xA;&#xA;It&#39;s by remarkable coincidence that the recently released Strange New Worlds episode &#34;Off-Hour&#34; reintroduced the character of Lt. Rahda just as I&#39;d finished &#34;That Which Survives&#34; and &#34;One Small Step&#34;. I don&#39;t think I&#39;ve seen anyone else mention this, but both episodes make reference to jettisoning a component; &#34;Off-Hour&#34; shows that Pike had to jettison the ion pod before it exploded. In &#34;That Which Survives&#34;, Enterprise is accelerating out of control, and Scotty is in a crawlway trying to access the flow valve to stop it. Spock orders Rahda to arm the jettison system in case something goes wrong. The crawlway isn&#39;t the ion pod, but it gets called a pod in dialog. Most commentary I&#39;ve seen compares the recent episode to &#34;Court Martial&#34;. I&#39;m not aware of any who have drawn the connection to &#34;That Which Survives,&#34; but it&#39;s an interesting mirroring of the situation in &#34;Off-Hour&#34;.&#xA;&#xA;That&#39;s just an observation. It&#39;s got nothing to do with the novel.&#xA;&#xA;The novel ends with Kirk jumping through the portal in pursuit of Tasm and Luz who absconded with the portal control device. &#xA;&#xA;This is sort of the conceit of the Gateways series. Novels 1 through 6 follow each series&#39; crew as they discover the gateway tech, culminating in one of our heroes jumping through the gateway. The last few chapters are hacked off and presented as short stories, collected in book 7. Whichever hero jumped through the portal needs to complete their mission and find their way back. In Kirk&#39;s case, the short story &#34;One Giant Leap,&#34; follows him exclusively as he is on the Petraw birth world, some 40000 lightyears from Earth. He needs to track down the portal control device and destroy it before the Petraw can make use of it, and then find his way home. Kirk explores the Petraw homeworld, learning about their culture and their way of life. To imagine a sapient, humanoid species with a eusocial culture is an interesting exercise, and I think it&#39;s mostly pulled off well. There might have been a missed opportunity to make the Petraw more insectoid than humanoid to fit with the whole beehive motif, but that&#39;s an aesthetic quibble.&#xA;&#xA;There&#39;s no mention of the Iconians. The gateway seems at this point to be Kalandan tech. Though it is mentioned that Losira&#39;s people were a breakaway group from a more oppressive regime. That might suggest Iconian influence, though the Kalandans were about 12000 years too late for direct contact. The Kalandans may have found and adapted Iconan tech, or developed the gateways independently. I guess I&#39;ll find out when I get to the rest of the series.&#xA;&#xA;StarTrek]]&gt;</description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Finished “One Small Step” by Susan Wright.</p>

<p><img src="https://pixelfed.social/storage/m/_v2/860925387620473976/f0975049d-79c41a/5uNtuLEJ198a/2Ir8Z4E88jrO3KjrWfPBfnOGocBjAbMAhY2o0dWO.png" alt="Cover art of the Star Trek Novel Gateways Book one of Seven, One Small Step by Susan Wright. The cover is framed with an Iconian gateway structure with stylized pillars on the side, rising to an archway across the top. Through the gateway is the Petraw homeworld; a large moon rises over the horizon of a rocky desert landscape with two fortress like structures, one fading to the background, and the other closer to the frame of the gateway.  The tagline reads &#34;The beginning of a cosmic saga that spans the galaxy!&#34;"></p>

<p>The story opens toward the end of the episode “That Which Survives”. Kirk, McCoy and Sulu are trapped on the Kalandan station surrounded by the 3 Losira replicants. Spock and a security guard beam down just in time to shoot the Kalandan defense computer and saves them. Kirk hails the ship for beamout, they have a little chat about beauty surviving.</p>

<p>The end.</p>

<p>After the credits, Enterprise tries to beam up the landing party, but the transporter is interrupted by the biofilter detecting the disease that killed off the Kalandans. The entire landing party is infected, and can&#39;t leave until they can find a cure. While they&#39;re working on a cure, they continue to explore the station, discovering the Kalandan living quarters, one of the control rooms, some other interesting things. They&#39;re able to get some computer access, but since the station is in lockdown, all the vital information is controlled by the defense computer, which the security officer, whose name is Reinhart, by the way, left in a smoldering mess.</p>



<p>Kirk reaches out to command, explains what they&#39;ve found, and is ordered not to allow the station to fall into enemy hands.</p>

<p>The activation of the Kalandan station yeeting Enterprise 900 lightyears away and Losira&#39;s repeated usage of the portal generates a massive power spike, which gets the attention of a Klingon ship, as well as a Petraw scout ship. The Petraw are a kindof eusocial humanoid species. Their scout ships are crewed by a half dozen or so individuals, who scour the galaxy to obtain interesting technology, which they then send back to their homeworld. To get their hands on alien technology, they often pursue elaborate con jobs. They gather as much information as they can, tapping into Enterprise&#39;s comms with Starfleet Command, and decide to pose as the descendants of the Kalandans to stake claim to the station.</p>

<p>The Klingons arrive first, itching for a fight. Enterprise fights back, but their warp engines are still offline following Losira&#39;s sabotage, so they&#39;re on the ropes. Then the Petraw claiming to be Kalandans arrive, blow the Klingons to scrap, and introduce themselves. And as icing on the cake, they just happen to have a vaccine treatment that will prevent the sporocite infection from becoming a virus, allowing the away team to safely beam back to the ship.</p>

<p>Kirk is naturally suspicious, but has no proof. So he has no choice but to play along diplomatically until he can gather more information. More Klingons will be on their way, but it will take them a few days to get there. He can&#39;t let the station fall into Klingon hands, but he can&#39;t be sure the Kalandans are who they say they are, so he&#39;s unsure if he can allow them to take it either. He agrees to team up with the Kalandans to explore the station and gather more information. The Petraw commander, Tasm, observed Kirk&#39;s attraction to Losira, so she tailored her appearance thinking she could use her feminine wiles to manipulate Kirk. But Kirk finds her advances off-putting.</p>

<p>Their medical officer, Luz, also assumes the form of a beautiful woman, targeting McCoy.</p>

<p>They discover the gateway system that the Losira replicant used to pop in and out of existence. The system that let her instantly appear at any part on the surface of the planet, and even travel to and from Enterprise while it was on its way back from where it was punted. The Petraw want this technology above anything else that might be available on the station. But Kirk recognizes that it can be dangerous in the wrong hands. But anyway, it&#39;s locked out by the defense computer, so they&#39;ve got to get it back into working order before it&#39;ll be of any use to anyone.</p>

<p>It&#39;s an interesting game of cat and mouse. The reader knows the Petraw aren&#39;t really Kalandans. Kirk is suspicious, but not certain. McCoy seems reticent to look a gift horse in the mouth. Especially when one of those gift horses talks the talk of a brilliant medical officer, and is also kinda hot. McCoy more than most of the crew seems to play the mark. Scotty and Spock are seldom in a position to question the Kalandan&#39;s authenticity, and the rest of the crew… well…</p>

<p>One thing I&#39;ve noticed with a few novels lately is the narrative&#39;s tendency to forget that the rest of the crew exist unless they&#39;re needed. Uhura and Chekov in particular are on the bridge, do their jobs when called on, but the narrative doesn&#39;t bring any attention to them unless they&#39;re needed to perform some action to move a particular scene forward. And one gets the impression that if Sulu weren&#39;t on the planet at the end of the episode, the novel would have forgotten about him too, except for a few instances where he needs to take command. The novel tries to give some of the background characters something to do, M&#39;Benga, Rahda, Reinhart, and even some original characters we&#39;ve never seen before. But falls into the common habit of forgetting members of the principle cast.</p>

<p>It&#39;s by remarkable coincidence that the recently released Strange New Worlds episode “Off-Hour” reintroduced the character of Lt. Rahda just as I&#39;d finished “That Which Survives” and “One Small Step”. I don&#39;t think I&#39;ve seen anyone else mention this, but both episodes make reference to jettisoning a component; “Off-Hour” shows that Pike had to jettison the ion pod before it exploded. In “That Which Survives”, Enterprise is accelerating out of control, and Scotty is in a crawlway trying to access the flow valve to stop it. Spock orders Rahda to arm the jettison system in case something goes wrong. The crawlway isn&#39;t the ion pod, but it gets called a pod in dialog. Most commentary I&#39;ve seen compares the recent episode to “Court Martial”. I&#39;m not aware of any who have drawn the connection to “That Which Survives,” but it&#39;s an interesting mirroring of the situation in “Off-Hour”.</p>

<p>That&#39;s just an observation. It&#39;s got nothing to do with the novel.</p>

<p>The novel ends with Kirk jumping through the portal in pursuit of Tasm and Luz who absconded with the portal control device.</p>

<p>This is sort of the conceit of the Gateways series. Novels 1 through 6 follow each series&#39; crew as they discover the gateway tech, culminating in one of our heroes jumping through the gateway. The last few chapters are hacked off and presented as short stories, collected in book 7. Whichever hero jumped through the portal needs to complete their mission and find their way back. In Kirk&#39;s case, the short story “One Giant Leap,” follows him exclusively as he is on the Petraw birth world, some 40000 lightyears from Earth. He needs to track down the portal control device and destroy it before the Petraw can make use of it, and then find his way home. Kirk explores the Petraw homeworld, learning about their culture and their way of life. To imagine a sapient, humanoid species with a eusocial culture is an interesting exercise, and I think it&#39;s mostly pulled off well. There might have been a missed opportunity to make the Petraw more insectoid than humanoid to fit with the whole beehive motif, but that&#39;s an aesthetic quibble.</p>

<p>There&#39;s no mention of the Iconians. The gateway seems at this point to be Kalandan tech. Though it is mentioned that Losira&#39;s people were a breakaway group from a more oppressive regime. That might suggest Iconian influence, though the Kalandans were about 12000 years too late for direct contact. The Kalandans may have found and adapted Iconan tech, or developed the gateways independently. I guess I&#39;ll find out when I get to the rest of the series.</p>

<p><a href="/social-media-book-report/tag:StarTrek" class="hashtag" rel="nofollow"><span>#</span><span class="p-category">StarTrek</span></a></p>
]]></content:encoded>
      <guid>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/one-small-step-by-susan-wright</guid>
      <pubDate>Tue, 01 Sep 2026 20:20:19 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title>&#34;The Hunting&#34; by Doris Beetem.</title>
      <link>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/the-hunting-by-doris-beetem</link>
      <description>&lt;![CDATA[Finished &#34;The Hunting&#34; by Doris Beetem. Part of the Star Trek: The New Voyages short story collection.&#xA;&#xA;Cover art of the Star Trek short story collection The New Voyages. Enterprise is seen orbiting ahead of what looks like some kind of station or space installation built on an asteroid. What looks like a civilian craft of some kind zooms by in the background.&#xA;&#xA;It was short. Even for a short story.&#xA;&#xA;Spock goes on a ritual hunt called the Mok farr, where a Vulcan must pursue a dangerous animal for the purpose of subduing and mind melding with it to get an understanding of its bestial nature. To understand the animals base emotions reminiscent of a Vulcan&#39;s own violent emotions. And yes, I&#39;m cribbing a little bit from Memory Beta, because it&#39;s really that brief.&#xA;&#xA;Anyway, McCoy finds out about this, and decides to go with him, because he thinks Spock might need help.&#xA;&#xA;Spock finds and melds with a predator called an owltiger. Apparently it got the name because it&#39;s a tiger, but its ears are reminiscent of an owl. Something goes wrong. The owltiger takes off, and so does Spock. Apparently the mind meld didn&#39;t completely finish, and now Spock thinks he&#39;s a tiger. A tiger that&#39;s wildly confused that its paws are now hands.&#xA;&#xA;McCoy needs to track him down, and entice him to return to camp until the affect can wear off. It&#39;s not really hijinks. It&#39;s a fairly interesting exploration of the Vulcan psyche, and an exploration of the relationship between the two.&#xA;&#xA;StarTrek]]&gt;</description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Finished “The Hunting” by Doris Beetem. Part of the Star Trek: The New Voyages short story collection.</p>

<p><img src="https://pixelfed.social/storage/m/_v2/860925387620473976/9a26d276d-23d3a8/KNlmWGRMmbFj/SLbKTdzoCIAL0t9I3UoMRam05tVUv9kX5eNaHMlN.png" alt="Cover art of the Star Trek short story collection The New Voyages. Enterprise is seen orbiting ahead of what looks like some kind of station or space installation built on an asteroid. What looks like a civilian craft of some kind zooms by in the background."></p>

<p>It was short. Even for a short story.</p>

<p>Spock goes on a ritual hunt called the Mok farr, where a Vulcan must pursue a dangerous animal for the purpose of subduing and mind melding with it to get an understanding of its bestial nature. To understand the animals base emotions reminiscent of a Vulcan&#39;s own violent emotions. And yes, I&#39;m cribbing a little bit from Memory Beta, because it&#39;s really that brief.</p>

<p>Anyway, McCoy finds out about this, and decides to go with him, because he thinks Spock might need help.</p>

<p>Spock finds and melds with a predator called an owltiger. Apparently it got the name because it&#39;s a tiger, but its ears are reminiscent of an owl. Something goes wrong. The owltiger takes off, and so does Spock. Apparently the mind meld didn&#39;t completely finish, and now Spock thinks he&#39;s a tiger. A tiger that&#39;s wildly confused that its paws are now hands.</p>

<p>McCoy needs to track him down, and entice him to return to camp until the affect can wear off. It&#39;s not really hijinks. It&#39;s a fairly interesting exploration of the Vulcan psyche, and an exploration of the relationship between the two.</p>

<p><a href="/social-media-book-report/tag:StarTrek" class="hashtag" rel="nofollow"><span>#</span><span class="p-category">StarTrek</span></a></p>
]]></content:encoded>
      <guid>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/the-hunting-by-doris-beetem</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 10 Aug 2026 22:27:13 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title>&#34;First Frontier&#34; by Diane Carey &amp; Dr. James I. Kirkland.</title>
      <link>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/first-frontier-by-diane-carey-and-dr</link>
      <description>&lt;![CDATA[It has been a long time coming, I tell ya! Finally finished &#34;First Frontier&#34; by Diane Carey &amp; Dr. James I. Kirkland. &#xA;&#xA;Cover art of the Star Trek novel &#34;First Frontier&#34; by Diane Carey &amp; Dr. James I. Kirkland. Kirk and Spock are pictured, brandishing their phasers with a velociraptor like creature that Memory Beta calls a dinosauroid behind them with a jungle background fading into the distance. The tagline reads &#34;Kirk is stranded in an alternate timeline as the fate of human existence hangs in the balance!&#34;&#xA;&#xA;It&#39;s been a rough checks notes uhg! 4½ months, with real life imposing over my reading schedule, which set me back quite a bit. But I finally got back to it.&#xA;&#xA;The story opens with Enterprise about to test an experimental shield system with Exeter and Farragut standing by on monitoring. For reasons that seem completely unnecessary to the plot, Kirk was injured on a previous mission; his leg is swollen. It will be fine eventually, as McCoy is keeping him pumped full of drugs, and insists the healing will go faster if he gets some rest. But Kirk insists on overseeing the experiment despite the injury. This whole plot element seems to serve no purpose except to unnecessarily hobble Kirk without really slowing him down at all, and show him putting on a tough face for the crew, and wouldn&#39;t have been missed if it were cut.&#xA;&#xA;!--more--&#xA;&#xA;During the experiment, something goes wrong. Kirk orders the test aborted, and when they gather their senses, Exeter and Farragut are gone, and they aren&#39;t able to reach Starfleet or any Federation contact at all. There is no Federation comm traffic anywhere.&#xA;&#xA;They encounter some Romulans, then some Klingons. The ship designs are clearly Romulan and Klingon, but not quite familiar to what Kirk and crew have encountered already. And they seem more interested in fighting each other, only turning chase to the Enterprise once the other is dealt with.&#xA;&#xA;I honestly forget at which point they rescue a Klingon. It was many months ago that I read that section, and when I finally got back to it, I forgot he was there. He just sort of came out of nowhere. Anyway, they rescue a Klingon, Roth. He has no idea who they are. He&#39;s never heard of the Federation or Earth, or Starfleet, and explains that the Klingons have been involved in a protracted war with the Romulans for decades.&#xA;&#xA;And there&#39;s another Klingon, Zalt, who is Roth&#39;s commander, and I forget at which point he came into the story too.&#xA;&#xA;After giving the Romulans the slip, they set course for Earth. And when they arrive, they find the entire planet covered with prehistoric jungle. No intelligent life at all. The local vegetation is somewhat similar to what should be there, but the fauna is completely alien; Variations of the dinosaurs and other prehistoric species that might have been had they not been wiped out by an asteroid. In fact, they find that the KT boundary shows no signs of an asteroid impact at all. However, the higher strata do show a repeated cycle of industrialization and warfare, as though some intelligence rose up only to wipe itself out repeatedly.&#xA;&#xA;They set course for Vulcan, encountering a Vulcan… I guess… privateer, might be the word I&#39;m looking for; kinda like a merchant fleet, but not above preemptive boarding action. From them they learn that Vulcan did embrace the teachings of Surak, just as they had in known history, but repeated encounters with the Klingons put them on the back foot. With no humans to allay up and form the Federation, they are insular, defending themselves, but not much else. And other would-be Federation worlds are either similarly isolated, or overthrown by the Klingons.&#xA;&#xA;Knowing that something happened in the past to change the course of Earth history, and Earth&#39;s affect on the galaxy, they need to travel back to fix whatever went wrong. They can&#39;t use a slingshot maneuver, because the Chicxulub asteroid was so far in the past that it would take them years to get there, and since they don&#39;t know the exact date of the impact, or the change that altered it, they could be off target by millions of years. So they settle on the next best thing; The Guardian of Forever.&#xA;&#xA;The landing party is Kirk, Spock, McCoy, two science officers; anthropologist Dale Bannon, Reenie, a Tibetan girl who volunteered to be Spock&#39;s assistant, and a couple of redshirts; Vernon and Emmendorf. And they bring the Klingons with them. I don&#39;t know why; so the dinosaurs can have something to snack on besides Redshirts, I suppose. And the Guardian sends them back to the late Cretaceous period.&#xA;&#xA;Bannon has a bit of an arc in this novel. He was on the first landing party on alt-Earth, and saw a teammate get eaten by raptors. He has PTSD, and is considering resigning from Starfleet. The problem is, there is no Starfleet to resign from anymore, and Kirk needs him to get it back. Kirk goes to &#39;talk&#39; to him. And it&#39;s… not great. It goes so badly that I thought at first the main arc of this subplot was going to be Kirk learning to give better pep-talks.&#xA;&#xA;Once in the Late Cretaceous, the story starts getting good.&#xA;&#xA;Look, I know I can be a bit glib with these summaries, and my snark might come across as negative, but I don&#39;t mean to imply that the novel wasn&#39;t good up until this point. Diane Carey&#39;s Star Trek work is good. I&#39;ve liked most of what I&#39;ve read of hers so far, and look forward to the next one. She has an interest in sailing, and that comes through in the narrative, as she brings a nautical flair to the story. I find her space combat scenes quite vivid. You will not be lost in an action sequence.&#xA;&#xA;But the first half was a lot of buildup, and I had some real life matters to attend to, which prevented me from fully appreciating much of it. And there were some flaws that really stood out. Kirk&#39;s leg, for one. And his poor handling of Bannon&#39;s issues. I mentioned that I&#39;d forgot the Klingons. And I&#39;m not alone. The narrative seemed to forget them as well, and this persists during survival period in the Late Cretaceous. It only brings them up when it needed to remind the reader that they were there, and to make Starfleet security look like bumbling fools when they escape. There&#39;s a lot going on, which leads naturally to some loose threads is all. Not a huge deal, but it&#39;s not unnoticed.&#xA;&#xA;Anyway, their first priority is survival, followed shortly by figuring out what prevented the Chicxulub asteroid, and how to stop it without a space ship.&#xA;&#xA;These few chapters kicking off the back half are fairly typical of the genre; protagonists awestruck by the immensity of dinosaurs while simultaneously running from them so as not to get eaten and/or stepped on. What the novel does fairly well here is to cover the cliché by highlighting the density of the environment. The land is teaming with life in this period. Your typical CG animated Discovery Channel documentary doesn&#39;t really do it justice. The landing party has to navigate dense jungle under the feet of massive sauropods, and pursued by carnivores, including the obligatory T-Rex. The jungles are dense, the rivers are teaming with fish, and the beasts themselves are not just a hazard by their immensity but by their numbers.&#xA;&#xA;They discover some dinosaurs who aren&#39;t supposed to be there; Dinosaurs from the future. Decedents of Troodons who call themselves Clan Ru, transplanted on another world, presumably by the Preservers or some other ancient alien intelligence, who themselves came back in time on a mission to divert the asteroid.&#xA;&#xA;The Troodons had a large brain cavity compared to other dinosaurs its size, and more dexterous forelimbs. They&#39;ve often been speculated to be a species with the potential to develop intelligence, possibly to the point of tool use, were it not for the asteroid. I don&#39;t know how seriously that factoid is taken in scientific circles now, or when the novel was written in the &#39;90s; the co-author of the novel, James Kirkland mentions it in the forward, and naturally they&#39;re building a pulp sci-fi novel here, so they&#39;re going to stretch it to its logical extreme. And the only other source I&#39;ve ever encountered that mentions it was very pop-sci leaning, so I&#39;ll just mention that it&#39;s not unheard of, and leave it at that. Troodons were smarter than the average dinosaur, and were it not for the asteroid, maaaaaaaybe might have had a shot at becoming the dominant intelligence on the planet.&#xA;&#xA;The discerning fan may want to know, then, if Troodons were so smart, then why did the Voyager writers go with hadrosaurs for the Voth? I don&#39;t know; just to be different, I guess. Maybe the writers were aware of the novel, as it was only a couple years old at that time, and even though they&#39;re not obligated to canonize licensed works, wanted to avoid some obvious comparisons, so choose the next dinosaur over. That&#39;s just speculation. Doesn&#39;t matter. And if you&#39;re wondering, yes, there&#39;s a stampede of hadrosaurs in the novel as well.&#xA;&#xA;I have some thoughts on comparison with the Voth that I want to mention though. It&#39;s a bit of an aside, but this is my project, and no one can stop me. This is something that &#34;First Frontier&#34; manages a fair bit more success with. And it all comes down to the origin of Clan Ru and the Voth.&#xA;&#xA;&#34;Distant Origin&#34; is a pretty good episode. Not just for Voyager, but in general. The writing is fairly well done, the performances and direction are often praised. But the Voth in concept have often bothered me, and some other fans as well, for how they fail to mesh with what we know of real life science.&#xA;&#xA;Star Trek is not hard sci-fi; it&#39;s fairly soft, downright squishy at times, and its science is often slap-dash. It occasionally tries to start with a solid scientific premise and expand on it for entertainment, but it didn&#39;t always do that, and sometimes fails when it does. Especially in biology. In fact, well into the Voyager era, it kindof gave up on it altogether. And that&#39;s fine; I know it&#39;s fiction, it doesn&#39;t always have to mesh with real life science…&#xA;&#xA;Look; There are many ways to engage with a piece of media, ranging from mindless popcorn munching to detailed literary analysis, and if some of us want to analyze the scientific basis of the premise, then that&#39;s fine too. It&#39;s all in good fun, and there&#39;s no need to piss on someone else&#39;s good time. So if you&#39;re one of those &#34;huweah, but it&#39;s all fiction anyway, so who cares, weah&#34; types, then feel free to go for a soda and come back when we&#39;re done.&#xA;&#xA;Basically, it&#39;s speculated in the episode that the Voth evolved on Earth, became intelligent, and moved out into space before the asteroid hit, and somehow left no trace.&#xA;&#xA;No, that doesn&#39;t mesh. There&#39;s a lot we still don&#39;t know about the prehistoric periods of Earth, but we know it well enough that if something like that had happened, we would see it in the geological record. And it just isn&#39;t there.&#xA;&#xA;If you look at humanity, where we are right now, we have industrial pollutants in the atmosphere, alloyed metals, plastics. There&#39;s shit in the air, shit in the water, shit in the soil, we even have shit in orbit. We, as humans have had such a massive impact on our planet that we&#39;ve named our current geological epoch the Anthropocene after ourselves. And we&#39;re only on the cusp of becoming spacefaring, assuming we ever do. If humanity was wiped out tomorrow, and 100 million years from now, the apes, or dolphins, or whatever species rose up to replace us developed the science to understand their planet&#39;s past, they would see an unmistakable human shaped footprint. And you&#39;re telling me that dinosaurs did that, and the evidence for this is on some distant sunken continent? The willing suspension of disbelief is doing too much work already to heap that premise on top of it.&#xA;&#xA;&#34;First Frontier&#34; and &#34;Distant Origin&#34; both started with that similar base premise; What if ... Dinosaurs!? &#34;First Frontier&#34; succeeds at this.&#xA;&#xA;&#34;Distant Origin&#34; absolutely succeeds at what it&#39;s trying to do; start with the premise, and use it to tell a story based on the trial of Galileo. It does this very well, and in the process it can&#39;t help but become a commentary on the evolution vs. creationism debates that were prevalent at the time (and arguably still today, though to be honest we&#39;ve kindof got bigger fish to fry these days). It doesn&#39;t outright fail at the base premise, but it staggers. That&#39;s not what it&#39;s trying to do, but I can&#39;t help but be a little bit disappointed that they didn&#39;t try to do that just a little bit harder.&#xA;&#xA;&#34;First Frontier&#34; avoids this by invoking the Preservers. To be sure, &#34;The Paradise Syndrome&#34; is a problematic episode from TOS, and I&#39;m sure there are more than a few TV writers in the &#39;90s who preferred not to invoke it. Especially as a line spoken by Chakotay, which would only highlight Voyager&#39;s own failings in that area, which by this point they&#39;d become well aware of.&#xA;&#xA;There&#39;s a fan theory out there that alien visitors like the Preservers, but not necessarily the Preservers are a better explanation for the Voth than the twisted logic Chakotay mutters. Star Trek writers in this era were often discouraged from mentioning deep lore like that. But the Preservers are a part of Star Trek lore that already exists, and addresses the problem much cleaner, and with less effort. And yeah, there&#39;s no evidence in real life for the Preservers either, but pick your poison. An alien visitor like the Preservers would leave a lot less trash behind than an entire technological civilization. Trash that they could either pack out themselves, or would have left such trace amounts behind that it would have been well within the margin of error in the geological record.&#xA;&#xA;Anyway, enough of that.&#xA;&#xA;Speaking of science in Science Fiction, the representation of science in the novel is delicious. I mentioned the co-author Dr. James I. Kirkland already. But he brought some delectables to the party that are quite welcome.&#xA;&#xA;The narrative could have kept better track of its moving pieces, the Klingons, the bridge crew, the Away team party, but what it lost in the chaos, it made up for in the setting, in the detail of the action. The scientific details blended with background worldbuilding. The Late Cretaceous was a busy place. Carnivores are vicious, ravenous monsters, and jungles are dense and heavily populated. Probably one of the better Star Trek with Dinosaurs adventures I&#39;ve encountered so far. The Strange New Worlds episode &#34;Valles Marineris&#34; is a close second, and that&#39;s grading on a curve, because it is a TV show and not a novel. I feel like maybe there was a comic too that I&#39;m forgetting.&#xA;&#xA;startrek&#xA;]]&gt;</description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It has been a long time coming, I tell ya! Finally finished “First Frontier” by Diane Carey &amp; Dr. James I. Kirkland.</p>

<p><img src="https://pixelfed.social/storage/m/_v2/860925387620473976/9a26d276d-23d3a8/uKnFh7lkeDya/HNjSy3HOtzimomtUKY8hLcIM8ZfCJjhqZTppJ38l.png" alt="Cover art of the Star Trek novel &#34;First Frontier&#34; by Diane Carey &amp; Dr. James I. Kirkland. Kirk and Spock are pictured, brandishing their phasers with a velociraptor like creature that Memory Beta calls a dinosauroid behind them with a jungle background fading into the distance. The tagline reads &#34;Kirk is stranded in an alternate timeline as the fate of human existence hangs in the balance!&#34;"></p>

<p>It&#39;s been a rough <em>checks notes</em> uhg! 4½ months, with real life imposing over my reading schedule, which set me back quite a bit. But I finally got back to it.</p>

<p>The story opens with Enterprise about to test an experimental shield system with Exeter and Farragut standing by on monitoring. For reasons that seem completely unnecessary to the plot, Kirk was injured on a previous mission; his leg is swollen. It will be fine eventually, as McCoy is keeping him pumped full of drugs, and insists the healing will go faster if he gets some rest. But Kirk insists on overseeing the experiment despite the injury. This whole plot element seems to serve no purpose except to unnecessarily hobble Kirk without really slowing him down at all, and show him putting on a tough face for the crew, and wouldn&#39;t have been missed if it were cut.</p>



<p>During the experiment, something goes wrong. Kirk orders the test aborted, and when they gather their senses, Exeter and Farragut are gone, and they aren&#39;t able to reach Starfleet or any Federation contact at all. There is no Federation comm traffic anywhere.</p>

<p>They encounter some Romulans, then some Klingons. The ship designs are clearly Romulan and Klingon, but not quite familiar to what Kirk and crew have encountered already. And they seem more interested in fighting each other, only turning chase to the Enterprise once the other is dealt with.</p>

<p>I honestly forget at which point they rescue a Klingon. It was many months ago that I read that section, and when I finally got back to it, I forgot he was there. He just sort of came out of nowhere. Anyway, they rescue a Klingon, Roth. He has no idea who they are. He&#39;s never heard of the Federation or Earth, or Starfleet, and explains that the Klingons have been involved in a protracted war with the Romulans for decades.</p>

<p>And there&#39;s another Klingon, Zalt, who is Roth&#39;s commander, and I forget at which point he came into the story too.</p>

<p>After giving the Romulans the slip, they set course for Earth. And when they arrive, they find the entire planet covered with prehistoric jungle. No intelligent life at all. The local vegetation is somewhat similar to what should be there, but the fauna is completely alien; Variations of the dinosaurs and other prehistoric species that might have been had they not been wiped out by an asteroid. In fact, they find that the KT boundary shows no signs of an asteroid impact at all. However, the higher strata do show a repeated cycle of industrialization and warfare, as though some intelligence rose up only to wipe itself out repeatedly.</p>

<p>They set course for Vulcan, encountering a Vulcan… I guess… privateer, might be the word I&#39;m looking for; kinda like a merchant fleet, but not above preemptive boarding action. From them they learn that Vulcan did embrace the teachings of Surak, just as they had in known history, but repeated encounters with the Klingons put them on the back foot. With no humans to allay up and form the Federation, they are insular, defending themselves, but not much else. And other would-be Federation worlds are either similarly isolated, or overthrown by the Klingons.</p>

<p>Knowing that something happened in the past to change the course of Earth history, and Earth&#39;s affect on the galaxy, they need to travel back to fix whatever went wrong. They can&#39;t use a slingshot maneuver, because the Chicxulub asteroid was so far in the past that it would take them years to get there, and since they don&#39;t know the exact date of the impact, or the change that altered it, they could be off target by millions of years. So they settle on the next best thing; The Guardian of Forever.</p>

<p>The landing party is Kirk, Spock, McCoy, two science officers; anthropologist Dale Bannon, Reenie, a Tibetan girl who volunteered to be Spock&#39;s assistant, and a couple of redshirts; Vernon and Emmendorf. And they bring the Klingons with them. I don&#39;t know why; so the dinosaurs can have something to snack on besides Redshirts, I suppose. And the Guardian sends them back to the late Cretaceous period.</p>

<p>Bannon has a bit of an arc in this novel. He was on the first landing party on alt-Earth, and saw a teammate get eaten by raptors. He has PTSD, and is considering resigning from Starfleet. The problem is, there is no Starfleet to resign from anymore, and Kirk needs him to get it back. Kirk goes to &#39;talk&#39; to him. And it&#39;s… not great. It goes so badly that I thought at first the main arc of this subplot was going to be Kirk learning to give better pep-talks.</p>

<p>Once in the Late Cretaceous, the story starts getting good.</p>

<p>Look, I know I can be a bit glib with these summaries, and my snark might come across as negative, but I don&#39;t mean to imply that the novel wasn&#39;t good up until this point. Diane Carey&#39;s Star Trek work is good. I&#39;ve liked most of what I&#39;ve read of hers so far, and look forward to the next one. She has an interest in sailing, and that comes through in the narrative, as she brings a nautical flair to the story. I find her space combat scenes quite vivid. You will not be lost in an action sequence.</p>

<p>But the first half was a lot of buildup, and I had some real life matters to attend to, which prevented me from fully appreciating much of it. And there were some flaws that really stood out. Kirk&#39;s leg, for one. And his poor handling of Bannon&#39;s issues. I mentioned that I&#39;d forgot the Klingons. And I&#39;m not alone. The narrative seemed to forget them as well, and this persists during survival period in the Late Cretaceous. It only brings them up when it needed to remind the reader that they were there, and to make Starfleet security look like bumbling fools when they escape. There&#39;s a lot going on, which leads naturally to some loose threads is all. Not a huge deal, but it&#39;s not unnoticed.</p>

<p>Anyway, their first priority is survival, followed shortly by figuring out what prevented the Chicxulub asteroid, and how to stop it without a space ship.</p>

<p>These few chapters kicking off the back half are fairly typical of the genre; protagonists awestruck by the immensity of dinosaurs while simultaneously running from them so as not to get eaten and/or stepped on. What the novel does fairly well here is to cover the cliché by highlighting the density of the environment. The land is teaming with life in this period. Your typical CG animated Discovery Channel documentary doesn&#39;t really do it justice. The landing party has to navigate dense jungle under the feet of massive sauropods, and pursued by carnivores, including the obligatory T-Rex. The jungles are dense, the rivers are teaming with fish, and the beasts themselves are not just a hazard by their immensity but by their numbers.</p>

<p>They discover some dinosaurs who aren&#39;t supposed to be there; Dinosaurs from the future. Decedents of Troodons who call themselves Clan Ru, transplanted on another world, presumably by the Preservers or some other ancient alien intelligence, who themselves came back in time on a mission to divert the asteroid.</p>

<p>The Troodons had a large brain cavity compared to other dinosaurs its size, and more dexterous forelimbs. They&#39;ve often been speculated to be a species with the potential to develop intelligence, possibly to the point of tool use, were it not for the asteroid. I don&#39;t know how seriously that factoid is taken in scientific circles now, or when the novel was written in the &#39;90s; the co-author of the novel, James Kirkland mentions it in the forward, and naturally they&#39;re building a pulp sci-fi novel here, so they&#39;re going to stretch it to its logical extreme. And the only other source I&#39;ve ever encountered that mentions it was very pop-sci leaning, so I&#39;ll just mention that it&#39;s not unheard of, and leave it at that. Troodons were smarter than the average dinosaur, and were it not for the asteroid, maaaaaaaybe might have had a shot at becoming the dominant intelligence on the planet.</p>

<p>The discerning fan may want to know, then, if Troodons were so smart, then why did the Voyager writers go with hadrosaurs for the Voth? I don&#39;t know; just to be different, I guess. Maybe the writers were aware of the novel, as it was only a couple years old at that time, and even though they&#39;re not obligated to canonize licensed works, wanted to avoid some obvious comparisons, so choose the next dinosaur over. That&#39;s just speculation. Doesn&#39;t matter. And if you&#39;re wondering, yes, there&#39;s a stampede of hadrosaurs in the novel as well.</p>

<p>I have some thoughts on comparison with the Voth that I want to mention though. It&#39;s a bit of an aside, but this is my project, and no one can stop me. This is something that “First Frontier” manages a fair bit more success with. And it all comes down to the origin of Clan Ru and the Voth.</p>

<p>“Distant Origin” is a pretty good episode. Not just for Voyager, but in general. The writing is fairly well done, the performances and direction are often praised. But the Voth in concept have often bothered me, and some other fans as well, for how they fail to mesh with what we know of real life science.</p>

<p>Star Trek is not hard sci-fi; it&#39;s fairly soft, downright squishy at times, and its science is often slap-dash. It occasionally tries to start with a solid scientific premise and expand on it for entertainment, but it didn&#39;t always do that, and sometimes fails when it does. Especially in biology. In fact, well into the Voyager era, it kindof gave up on it altogether. And that&#39;s fine; I know it&#39;s fiction, it doesn&#39;t always have to mesh with real life science…</p>

<p>Look; There are many ways to engage with a piece of media, ranging from mindless popcorn munching to detailed literary analysis, and if some of us want to analyze the scientific basis of the premise, then that&#39;s fine too. It&#39;s all in good fun, and there&#39;s no need to piss on someone else&#39;s good time. So if you&#39;re one of those “huweah, but it&#39;s all fiction anyway, so who cares, weah” types, then feel free to go for a soda and come back when we&#39;re done.</p>

<p>Basically, it&#39;s speculated in the episode that the Voth evolved on Earth, became intelligent, and moved out into space before the asteroid hit, and somehow left no trace.</p>

<p>No, that doesn&#39;t mesh. There&#39;s a lot we still don&#39;t know about the prehistoric periods of Earth, but we know it well enough that if something like that had happened, we would see it in the geological record. And it just isn&#39;t there.</p>

<p>If you look at humanity, where we are right now, we have industrial pollutants in the atmosphere, alloyed metals, plastics. There&#39;s shit in the air, shit in the water, shit in the soil, we even have shit in orbit. We, as humans have had such a massive impact on our planet that we&#39;ve named our current geological epoch the Anthropocene after ourselves. And we&#39;re only on the cusp of becoming spacefaring, assuming we ever do. If humanity was wiped out tomorrow, and 100 million years from now, the apes, or dolphins, or whatever species rose up to replace us developed the science to understand their planet&#39;s past, they would see an unmistakable human shaped footprint. And you&#39;re telling me that dinosaurs did that, and the evidence for this is on some distant sunken continent? The willing suspension of disbelief is doing too much work already to heap that premise on top of it.</p>

<p>“First Frontier” and “Distant Origin” both started with that similar base premise; What if ... Dinosaurs!? “First Frontier” succeeds at this.</p>

<p>“Distant Origin” absolutely succeeds at what it&#39;s trying to do; start with the premise, and use it to tell a story based on the trial of Galileo. It does this very well, and in the process it can&#39;t help but become a commentary on the evolution vs. creationism debates that were prevalent at the time (and arguably still today, though to be honest we&#39;ve kindof got bigger fish to fry these days). It doesn&#39;t outright fail at the base premise, but it staggers. That&#39;s not what it&#39;s trying to do, but I can&#39;t help but be a little bit disappointed that they didn&#39;t try to do that just a little bit harder.</p>

<p>“First Frontier” avoids this by invoking the Preservers. To be sure, “The Paradise Syndrome” is a problematic episode from TOS, and I&#39;m sure there are more than a few TV writers in the &#39;90s who preferred not to invoke it. Especially as a line spoken by Chakotay, which would only highlight Voyager&#39;s own failings in that area, which by this point they&#39;d become well aware of.</p>

<p>There&#39;s a fan theory out there that alien visitors like the Preservers, but not necessarily the Preservers are a better explanation for the Voth than the twisted logic Chakotay mutters. Star Trek writers in this era were often discouraged from mentioning deep lore like that. But the Preservers are a part of Star Trek lore that already exists, and addresses the problem much cleaner, and with less effort. And yeah, there&#39;s no evidence in real life for the Preservers either, but pick your poison. An alien visitor like the Preservers would leave a lot less trash behind than an entire technological civilization. Trash that they could either pack out themselves, or would have left such trace amounts behind that it would have been well within the margin of error in the geological record.</p>

<p>Anyway, enough of that.</p>

<p>Speaking of science in Science Fiction, the representation of science in the novel is delicious. I mentioned the co-author Dr. James I. Kirkland already. But he brought some delectables to the party that are quite welcome.</p>

<p>The narrative could have kept better track of its moving pieces, the Klingons, the bridge crew, the Away team party, but what it lost in the chaos, it made up for in the setting, in the detail of the action. The scientific details blended with background worldbuilding. The Late Cretaceous was a busy place. Carnivores are vicious, ravenous monsters, and jungles are dense and heavily populated. Probably one of the better Star Trek with Dinosaurs adventures I&#39;ve encountered so far. The Strange New Worlds episode “Valles Marineris” is a close second, and that&#39;s grading on a curve, because it is a TV show and not a novel. I feel like maybe there was a comic too that I&#39;m forgetting.</p>

<p><a href="/social-media-book-report/tag:startrek" class="hashtag" rel="nofollow"><span>#</span><span class="p-category">startrek</span></a></p>
]]></content:encoded>
      <guid>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/first-frontier-by-diane-carey-and-dr</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 10 Aug 2026 01:48:17 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title>&#34;The Badlands, Part I&#34; by Susan Wright </title>
      <link>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/the-badlands-part-i-by-susan-wright</link>
      <description>&lt;![CDATA[Finished &#34;The Badlands, Part I&#34; by Susan Wright &#xA;&#xA;Cover art of the Star Trek novel The Badlands by Susan Wright. The Enterprise D is pictured at the top, with the TOS Enterprise pictured at the bottom with the title between them. Behind them both is starfield boarded by purple and orange swirling clouds. The tagline reads &#34;Beginning a suspense-filled saga that unites the Star Trek universe!&#34;&#xA;&#xA;That is to say I&#39;ve finished the first half of a novel in which the second half is Next Gen. I intend to finish it, later, when I get to Next Gen. Which probably means that I&#39;m going to have to re-read part 1 when I get there to remind myself what happened.&#xA;&#xA;Kirk is ordered to a point outside of claimed space to intercept a smuggler who Starfleet believes is carrying information about the Romulan plasma weapon that they&#39;d first encountered in &#34;Balance of Terror&#34; way back in early Season 1. They find the titular Badlands, which Starfleet is apparently largely unaware of. They capture who they believe to be the smuggler, and bring them aboard, and have an entanglement with a Romulan Bird of Prey. There&#39;s a radiation burst, which destroys the Romulan ship, and the Enterprise crew is hit with dangerous and mysterious form of gamma radiation. A bunch of the crew get sick with radiation poisoning. &#xA;&#xA;The Klingons show up, and they play cat and mouse with them for a while, while Kirk tries to get information about the plasma weapon out of their captured smuggler.&#xA;&#xA;I&#39;m going to reserve comment on it, since it&#39;s only the first half of the first novel of a 2 novel series. When I get to Part 2, I might have more to say. But it&#39;s a pretty reasonable start so far.&#xA;&#xA;StarTrek]]&gt;</description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Finished “The Badlands, Part I” by Susan Wright</p>

<p><img src="https://pixelfed.social/storage/m/_v2/860925387620473976/a1431798c-70628a/B8CdOxhnmtag/weFtmtJf1zafXTdIatgsl0PZE6X1lCxl7Im5A1ha.png" alt="Cover art of the Star Trek novel The Badlands by Susan Wright. The Enterprise D is pictured at the top, with the TOS Enterprise pictured at the bottom with the title between them. Behind them both is starfield boarded by purple and orange swirling clouds. The tagline reads &#34;Beginning a suspense-filled saga that unites the Star Trek universe!&#34;"></p>

<p>That is to say I&#39;ve finished the first half of a novel in which the second half is Next Gen. I intend to finish it, later, when I get to Next Gen. Which probably means that I&#39;m going to have to re-read part 1 when I get there to remind myself what happened.</p>

<p>Kirk is ordered to a point outside of claimed space to intercept a smuggler who Starfleet believes is carrying information about the Romulan plasma weapon that they&#39;d first encountered in “Balance of Terror” way back in early Season 1. They find the titular Badlands, which Starfleet is apparently largely unaware of. They capture who they believe to be the smuggler, and bring them aboard, and have an entanglement with a Romulan Bird of Prey. There&#39;s a radiation burst, which destroys the Romulan ship, and the Enterprise crew is hit with dangerous and mysterious form of gamma radiation. A bunch of the crew get sick with radiation poisoning.</p>

<p>The Klingons show up, and they play cat and mouse with them for a while, while Kirk tries to get information about the plasma weapon out of their captured smuggler.</p>

<p>I&#39;m going to reserve comment on it, since it&#39;s only the first half of the first novel of a 2 novel series. When I get to Part 2, I might have more to say. But it&#39;s a pretty reasonable start so far.</p>

<p><a href="/social-media-book-report/tag:StarTrek" class="hashtag" rel="nofollow"><span>#</span><span class="p-category">StarTrek</span></a></p>
]]></content:encoded>
      <guid>https://rant.li/social-media-book-report/the-badlands-part-i-by-susan-wright</guid>
      <pubDate>Tue, 24 Mar 2026 18:47:55 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
  </channel>
</rss>